• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Results:How would you rate "Dark Water" ... ?
Excellent
332 (63.36%)
Good
113 (21.56%)
Average
36 (6.87%)
Meh!
21 (4.01%)
Rubbish!
22 (4.20%)
Voters: 524. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Doctor Who - S8E11 - Dark Water - 1st Nov '14 - BBC One (HD) @ 8.15pm
<<
<
14 of 42
>>
>
lordOfTime
01-11-2014
Well this is a game changer isn't it. Except is their precedent in classic who for gender change in time lords?
Sawyl Gwilym
01-11-2014
When Missy said she was the Time Lady the Doctor left behind abandoned, I was convinced it was going to be Romana. When she later said Missy was short for Mistress, I thought the next line would be something about K9. Until then I'd thought she was some sort of future version of Clara. It was so glaringly obvious that she would turn out to be the Master that I think a great many people would have overlooked it.

Intrigued and excited now to see how this plays out next week.
CELT1987
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Morgsie:
“Gobsmacked”

So was the Doctor when The Master kissed him...
Lady of Traken
01-11-2014
And 50 years of heritage just got trashed as Missy is the Master. How conceited of Moffatt. Absolutely hated the revelation. Romana or Rani yes but not this
Sarah_James3
01-11-2014
What was the point of the episode. Found it very disturbing and upsetting. As someone who has lost her mum recently I found it very upsetting and sick to mention the dead are still alive when they are cremated. Those words will haunt me. Thanks steven Moffat that is not entertaining and I worked out a few weeks ago that missy was the master so obvious. You can not bring back the dead and the doctor should not go there
Inspiration
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by 2shy2007:
“I would rather see it cancelled than that happen.”

I was kidding people I was kidding!
StressMonkey
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Inspiration:
“Theres still hope that Miranda Hart will be the doctor one day then.”

Dear lord no

I can not stand Miranda. I will actively avoid anything she's in now because she is so consistently toe curlingly awful.

Thankfully there are so many brilliant British actresses we don't have to be landed with MH should we have a female Dr
CrowleySr
01-11-2014
42 minutes of filler for the finale, and two big reveals. Already knew about the Cybermen, now Missy is the Master. Whatever, I doubt we'll ever see a female Doctor. Too close to stunt casting

Making her the Valeyard would have been more interesting
Bob_1971
01-11-2014
If Moffatt can explain how the master escaped, why she is on earth, why the cybermen are converting the dead, rescue danny pink, and foil the masters dastardly scheme -- all in the space of 45 minutes, I'll eat my hat!
icemetallica8
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by 2shy2007:
“Not happy that Moffat has decided that time lords can become time ladies, not happy at all, you know what will come next, a damn female Doctor ”

Didn't necessarily regenerate into a female, maybe he took over a female body?

Originally Posted by ukcarter:
“Can somebody refresh my memory - when we last saw the end of the master, didn't it end with a teaser shot of a female hand? I'm very hazy here.”

No, a lady lifted his ring, then he was 're-born' out of a ceremony after that. Last time we seen him he sent the Time Lords back to their time.
ArthurJBear
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by 2shy2007:
“Not happy that Moffat has decided that time lords can become time ladies, not happy at all, you know what will come next, a damn female Doctor ”

This is not new news it was already established in The Doctor's Wife that Time Lords could change sex with the Corsair (and non-cannonically in Big Finish's DW Unbound: Exile)
slouchingthatch
01-11-2014
Okay, how many people hated that? Because I actually quite liked it - far better to be the Master than the Rani or even Romana. Even reviewers weren't told it was the Master (those scenes were deleted from previews).

For anyone who's interested, here's my review of the first half of the season finale, which I actually quite enjoyed --> Link
Billy_Value
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by saladfingers81:
“No it hasn't. That was pure classic Doctor Who. Best of Moffat and RTD with a side order of Classic who. But don't let that stop you trotting out the same tired old meaningless buzz phrase”

forbid anyone to have an opinion
2shy2007
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Inspiration:
“I was kidding people I was kidding! ”

Thank christ for that then!! Moffat really cheeses me off sometimes, lets hope that instead of regeneration, he stole the body a la Cassandra, there can NEVER be a female Doctor.
James Frederick
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by JR_THELEGEND:
“That's the only drawback on the reveal. But I highly doubt the BBC would risk killing the series of by making the Doctor a female to make a handful of the PC brigade happy.”

Or by making black as many of the same viewers have said if they make him black they will stop watching.

Or they could ignore the idiots and cast whoever is best for the show no matter of gender or colour.
Dogmatix
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Lady of Traken:
“And 50 years of heritage just got trashed as Missy is the Master. How conceited of Moffatt. Absolutely hated the revelation. Romana or Rani yes but not this ”

Agreed.
ukcarter
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by icemetallica8:
“Didn't necessarily regenerate into a female, maybe he took over a female body?



No, a lady lifted his ring, then he was 're-born' out of a ceremony after that. Last time we seen him he sent the Time Lords back to their time.”


Aha! Thank You.
bbll22
01-11-2014
For the first half of a finale, it didn't really get going for me until the last 10 minutes. Too much time was spent setting everything up with so few characters that it dragged for me a little in the first part.

Still not keen on Peter in anyway; his rudeness is just beyond annoying as the main character for me, it's just not right. clara's swaying emotions didn't make me feel sorry for her either if I'm honest, not at all consistent in this at all.

The whole reveal around the skeletons being Cybermen wasn't a surprise sadly due to the fact we knew they were already going to be in the episode so that was a bit flat sadly.

The CGI at times felt a bit iffy too but at least the directing was good. Chris Addison less so though....

Missy being who she was wasn't so much of a surprise either and it didn't give me a shock kind of feeling at all. The intentions behind the reveal were good it just wasn't done too well sadly...that's where the credits should have cut in, it would have been more impactful that way.

Overall it was ok but I'm oddly not too eager to see next week's finale which obviously is a shame...
oathy
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by CrowleySr:
“42 minutes of filler for the finale, and two big reveals. Already knew about the Cybermen, now Missy is the Master. Whatever, I doubt we'll ever see a female Doctor. Too close to stunt casting

Making her the Valeyard would have been more interesting”

yep that was my guess tbh
It might just be moffat giving people a kick in the wot nots missy dies and regenerates into someone else next week. I wouldn't be a bit surprised theres some huge twist linked with this.
Muttley76
01-11-2014
Well, I really loved that! The cliffhangers were all amazing and I think the big reveal was played to perfection, but actually what I loved about this episode the most was how it toyed with the perceptions and expectations of the audience throughout - really terrifically written and plotted, imho. 10/10.
k9fan
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Lady of Traken:
“And 50 years of heritage just got trashed as Missy is the Master. How conceited of Moffatt. Absolutely hated the revelation. Romana or Rani yes but not this ”

Originally Posted by Sarah_James3:
“What was the point of the episode. Found it very disturbing and upsetting. As someone who has lost her mum recently I found it very upsetting and sick to mention the dead are still alive when they are cremated. Those words will haunt me. Thanks steven Moffat that is not entertaining and I worked out a few weeks ago that missy was the master so obvious. You can not bring back the dead and the doctor should not go there”


I agree entirely, especially with the latter post.
My parents died too young, long ago, but I still feel their loss.
CrowleySr
01-11-2014
The obvious out is the Master went back to his body snatching ways (Tremas)

A female Master (or Doctor) can't work. Is Michelle Gomez really playing the same character as Roger Delgado? That's suspending too much belief
Dan-Bevis
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Sarah_James3:
“What was the point of the episode. Found it very disturbing and upsetting. As someone who has lost her mum recently I found it very upsetting and sick to mention the dead are still alive when they are cremated. Those words will haunt me. Thanks steven Moffat that is not entertaining and I worked out a few weeks ago that missy was the master so obvious. You can not bring back the dead and the doctor should not go there”

I'm sorry that you've lost someone you love recently, but the goal of making The Doctor and Clara question what it means to be dead was meant to be a cruel and uncomfortable moment by that doctor guy [unknowably puppeted by 'Missy'] as prep for the Cybermen reveal.
ryanr554
01-11-2014
Easily the best episode this series. I thought it was absolutely fantastic. Started off pretty slow but got better and better as it went along. There is a lot of explaining to do like how the Master escaped from Gallifrey, when he regenerate, why he is using Cybermen etc

I can't wait for next week. If the quality holds up it will be the best finale of NuWho ever.
gilesb
01-11-2014
Originally Posted by Bob_1971:
“If Moffatt can explain how the master escaped, why she is on earth, why the cybermen are converting the dead, rescue danny pink, and foil the masters dastardly scheme -- all in the space of 45 minutes, I'll eat my hat!”

Don't worry next week is extended, I think to 60 minutes.
<<
<
14 of 42
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map