Originally Posted by ShAneOmaC2005:
“Big difference is Ella was actually talented. She had something going for her. Even 1d had stage presence and chemistry. I have not seen anything to suggest SK have anything unique or talented to offer other than the fact there is 8 of them, that does not automatically make them unique. Currently it is quite obviously working against them, now if they had chemistry and talent that would be a different story. I don't think they have any potential to be a big hit. I am sure Simon knows this by now but it is his own ego that wants to prove himself right. Even when he knows he has no chance.”
Where was the chemistry with 1D? Do you know how much stick and negativity they received on this very page on DS??? They were very unpopular and called all names under the sun on this forum.I hope you have been long enough on this forum to know its double standards.
1D were vocally weaker.Liam was a reject from the year before.They can be all praises on this forum for now but there was none at this time on the XFactor.They benefited from being the only boy band at the time to avoid the bottom 2.It was nothing to do their talent or charisma.Simon was their mentor which helped with song choices.