So out of all the past judges who are not currently on the show (Permanent Judges) which do you want to see back, which do you think will be back and who do you think will never return.

Who I Want Back

Tulisa
Gary Barlow

Who I think Will Return

Tulisa
Nicole


Who I Think Won't Return

Danni
Gary Barlow
Sharon Osborne

I want Dannii back but she won't return.

I'd like Danni or Nicole back - both better than Cheryl. Louie needs to go too - waste of a fourth judge - when someone far more knowledgeable and current could do the job.

Like to return:
Danni
Tulisa

Will return:
Tulisa

Won't return:
Gary
Sharon
Nicole
Danni

Like to Return
Kelly Rowland
Nicole Scherzinger


I think will Return
Tulisa

Won't Return
Gary
Sharon
Danni

Want to return: Kelly Rolland and Dani
Will return: Tulisa
Won't return : Kelly, Gary, Dani, Sharon

I want to return: Kelly, Danni

Will return: Tulisa

Won't return: Gary, Sharon, Danni

I think Nicole could both return if approached correctly, hence why Kelly R did the US show after we all thought she hated the show. And Nicole said yes to two UK series after being fired in the US.

Like to return
Mrs O
Nicole
Gary

Will return
Tulisa

I don't want to return
Cheryl
Mel B
Kelly R
Danii