I thought he would smash it, but it came across, to me at least as a watered down pop version

I thought it would be epic and it just wasn't

I thought he was amazing. Best performance by a long way.

really? compare it his audition

it was just meh for me

Are you kidding? I missed the first 30 seconds or so, but from what I saw it was incredible. And he had real confidence as well, it looked so effortless.

I thought t was his best.

Not a typical ballad, he moved, he put emotion in and has real grit in his voice!

It was AMAZING..the best vocal in this show this year...waited to hear this all day...and he didn't disapoint
Loved it..even slighty better than the first week! !!

Lucky he gets good songs

He was utterly incredible, as ever

I disagree with OP. I thought it was the strongest performance this year so far. He did fantastically

He did Smash It!!

Loved it

Andrea didn't do it for me tonight, I'm sad to say.

I haven't really liked any of his performances since Earth Song in Week One, mostly because of the poor song choices. I hated the excessive warbling at the end of tonight's performance.

Fleur was the best for me tonight.

TOTALLY TOTALLY SMASHED IT - Just like I knew he would. Best performance of the series by far. Incredible.

Loved it; especially the falsetto 😊

He was phenomenal. Even I thought that... and I'm not overly bothered about Andrea (I only really tuned in for Fleur).

I hate when people spout stuff like this, but Andrea is TOTALLY in a league of his own in this contest and tonight proved it.

Just had a listen to his performance. I was disappointed, because he has the perfect voice for it and he is capable of better.

His choices musically were hit and miss. His timing was off in a few places, and the riffing made him fall off the melody a few times, which distracted from the song and from how amazing his voice is.

I love listening to Andrea and think he is great at his best, my favorite singer of the season,in fact,but if his voice was anything less than spectacular, it wouldn't have worked .I was still impressed, but, though there were moments of brilliance and wow factor, only by how great the instrument is,not by the delivery.

One trick pony, every weeks the same no matter the song it's warble warble warble. Very boring and there's not a chance he'll win.

Yes! 100% this!

I wouldn't just buy his music, I'd pay good money to see him sing live after tonight more than ever, his voice just gets me.

I thought he was excellent, as usual.

No denying he was pretty amazing

Vocally he is untouchable. Yet another flawless vocal master class.

I do worry that it's going a bit same old same old for me...but then again, that didn't stop Sam Bailey from winning last year.

He's done two fast songs the last two weeks, he's changing it up!

What I meant was he hasn't done anything contemporary. Something that you would hear on the radio today. The arrangements of the songs he sung so far have been very dated.