Originally Posted by E05297535:
“I wasnt trying to be clever when I stated this. ...Paul didn't do himself any favours tbh as his time spent on the show often came over negatively during the live shows. ..before this, he was tipped to win it.... the final straw being his tantrum about the Meatloaf song, which he sang very well. Paul was one I rooted for to win the beginning. .last year even.....but his ' manner' and lack of excitement during the show turned me off him big time. ...this could have had the same impact on alot of voters who probably thought the same too, I dont know...it was Andrea who drew my interest, as I said before...and not by his voice either!!!! He would, imo, be worthy of the title more than Paul!! And now, I hope he is rewarded with it toi”
I hope you won't take this as condescending, because I don't mean it to be or feel that way, but it was the use of note perfect to describe Andrea that I was disagreeing with. That is something that isn't a matter of opinion, and I see it misused a lot.When he gets excited, and very into a song, which is a joy to hear and see, it sometimes makes Andrea lose the melody and causes pitch and timing issues( that wouldn't be there otherwise as he does have very good pitch generally), where Paul is consistently close to perfect in those things even when he throws in a spontaneous addlib(perhaps too much so, as I have stated before) If what you actually meant to say Andrea is the singer with the most exciting approach and the best voice, I actually agree with you,though I think Paul is great ,too.