Sounds lively. http://tellymix.co.uk/reality-tv/the...r-results.html

Most of that happened on The Xtra Factor.

.....Where Louis took the opportunity to add to being a stooge for Simon and the producers by once again displaying that to go with it he has the wettest as in no sense of humour I think I have ever seen.....all that rubbish on Xtra Factor about Mel's shoes and Gerry's photo was so off the pace of what was happening and was typical of the kind of insignificant idiot that he is when it comes to creating fun or humour its almost as if he is dead or at the very least very very old and out of touch and unable to keep up........he just can't do it......he has no idea of wit or irony whatsoever and just spits back with a sub-obvious comment like a child whenever Simon does his average quality jibes and wind ups.

........ and expecting anyone to believe that 'he couldn't decide' is a lowpoint even for this show.

Rubbish. Bet you Louis and Mel walk out hand in hand like they've done all series. They seem like the pair that get on with each other the best.

I agree totally, Louis should have gone long ago, he is so out of touch and such an old codger. I am totally sure that Simon only keeps him there to sway the votes in his favour and the producers and he has no say of his own but is just a puppet for the top people there. It's no wonder that Gary Barlow found Louis so frustrating and got angry with him a number of times whilst he was there. They should bring back Gary with Cheryl and Danni, people who will actually stand up to Simon!

Gary and Dannii yes, but with Sharon and not Cheryl

Dannii is Australian version ..she can't come back... And Gary won't come back. .

That's a shame. I thought Barlow did a good job.

A publicity stunt, Mel helped throw Paul under the bus, for someone who allegedly supports her act, she was more than happy to promote the impression that he was uncooperative and difficult over song choices, which were totally unsuitable, as did Cheryl, reminding him to take notice of his mentor. It was taking notice that cost him his place, together with the hatchet job Cowell instigated.

He has the talent, what he lacked was the cute factor, and a decent sob story.

All the judges have to toe the Cowell line to keep their jobs. Gary believed in talent alone, I doubt he would have agreed or gone along with the blatant manipulation, no wonder he didn't, want to stay, and cowell didn't want him in the first place.

I doubt Dannii would agree to work with Sharon...

She does have a point...even if it was just done for publicity.

BIB no he didn't as Frankie Cocozza illustrated that point