Originally Posted by darthbibble:
“With The Master now a woman they'd have to redesign it as it always did look a bit like a vibrator!”
“With The Master now a woman they'd have to redesign it as it always did look a bit like a vibrator!”
Results:Multiple Choice - Your Favourite Master(s)
Roger Delgado (1971-1973)
88 (60.69%)
Peter Pratt (The Deadly Assassin, 1976)
15 (10.34%)
Geoffrey Beevers (The Keeper of Traken, 1981)
11 (7.59%)
Anthony Ainley (1981-1989)
47 (32.41%)
Eric Roberts (Doctor Who Movie, 1996)
2 (1.38%)
Derek Jacobi (Utopia, 2007)
58 (40.00%)
John Simm (2007-2010)
31 (21.38%)
Michelle Gomez (2014)
66 (45.52%)
Voters: 145. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Favourite Masters (Multiple Choice)
2 of 2
Originally Posted by darthbibble:
“With The Master now a woman they'd have to redesign it as it always did look a bit like a vibrator!”
“With The Master now a woman they'd have to redesign it as it always did look a bit like a vibrator!”
Don't be silly.
Oh . . wait . . you may have a point.
I'm still not sure about the Master in the movie counting as a regeneration. The Master took the body over and ran it into the ground, as I remember. It was a human body with only one heart, not Gallifreyan.
Originally Posted by Dogmatix:
“I'm still not sure about the Master in the movie counting as a regeneration. The Master took the body over and ran it into the ground, as I remember. It was a human body with only one heart, not Gallifreyan.”
“I'm still not sure about the Master in the movie counting as a regeneration. The Master took the body over and ran it into the ground, as I remember. It was a human body with only one heart, not Gallifreyan.”
Another question (or two)
Are the decayed versions of The Master played by Peter Pratt and Geoffery Beevers two seperate or just one incarnation?
Further to that if they are one incarnation are they just the decayed version of the Delgado Master and all three of them are playing the same incarnation?
I always assumed that Peter Pratt and Geoffrey Beevers were playing the same crispy character so the same incarnation. As for them being a badly burnt Delgado Master, I always assumed not for some reason though I don't *think* it was ever stated one way or t'other?
Originally Posted by Dogmatix:
“I'm still not sure about the Master in the movie counting as a regeneration. The Master took the body over and ran it into the ground, as I remember. It was a human body with only one heart, not Gallifreyan.”
“I'm still not sure about the Master in the movie counting as a regeneration. The Master took the body over and ran it into the ground, as I remember. It was a human body with only one heart, not Gallifreyan.”
Doesn't that account for Tremas too?
Delgado by a country mile followed by Ainley (particularly in Survival). Delgado played the single best bad guy in the shows 51 year history.
"Ah Miss Grant, regretfully I must kill you.. but I did so enjoy our chat"
I don't see any of the post-Ainley Masters as the character.
"Ah Miss Grant, regretfully I must kill you.. but I did so enjoy our chat"
I don't see any of the post-Ainley Masters as the character.
Delgado and Gomez. Both had their own interpretation of the Master and his/her motivations. Gomez in particular had a completely different take on how to achieve her aims - not attempt to confound the Doctor, but make his nature part of the scheme.
Ainley suffered from having to pretend to be Delgado (except in 'Survivall' where he showed a different aspect). Simm chewed every piece of scenery in sight, as did Roberts. Pratt and Beevers (with respect - it's the role they were given) were scenery. Jacobi doesn't really count to my mind as he had so little screen-time actually as the Master and as the Professor just irritated me with his over-niceness.
Ainley suffered from having to pretend to be Delgado (except in 'Survivall' where he showed a different aspect). Simm chewed every piece of scenery in sight, as did Roberts. Pratt and Beevers (with respect - it's the role they were given) were scenery. Jacobi doesn't really count to my mind as he had so little screen-time actually as the Master and as the Professor just irritated me with his over-niceness.
Hi all! Haven't visited the "Who" forum since the end of August, as I didn't want to come face to face with any spoilers to do with the current series.
Now that it's ended, I can happily visit again.
I voted for Anthony Ainley as my first choice, and Roger Delgado second. I do like Ainley's Master quite a lot. My most favourite AA Master quote has to be, "Oh, my dear Doctor, you have been naïve!" And my favourite AA Master story is The Mark of the Rani. Both Kate O' Mara and Anthony were great together!
I'm not sure about Series 8, to be quite honest. I'm still in two halves about how much I liked it. If I had to say now, I'd probably give S8 a 6, maybe a 7 overall.
Anyway, Nick Frost as Father Christmas eh?
Looking forward to it. He's certainly the right size that Santa was.
Now that it's ended, I can happily visit again.
I voted for Anthony Ainley as my first choice, and Roger Delgado second. I do like Ainley's Master quite a lot. My most favourite AA Master quote has to be, "Oh, my dear Doctor, you have been naïve!" And my favourite AA Master story is The Mark of the Rani. Both Kate O' Mara and Anthony were great together!
I'm not sure about Series 8, to be quite honest. I'm still in two halves about how much I liked it. If I had to say now, I'd probably give S8 a 6, maybe a 7 overall.
Anyway, Nick Frost as Father Christmas eh?
Looking forward to it. He's certainly the right size that Santa was.
Everyone but Simm and Roberts. John Simm just didn't work for me as a character and Eric Roberts looked like he had stepped out of a trying too hard to look cool 80's American series e.g The Equilizer or the like.
Originally Posted by Michael_Eve:
“I always assumed that Peter Pratt and Geoffrey Beevers were playing the same crispy character so the same incarnation. As for them being a badly burnt Delgado Master, I always assumed not for some reason though I don't *think* it was ever stated one way or t'other?”
“I always assumed that Peter Pratt and Geoffrey Beevers were playing the same crispy character so the same incarnation. As for them being a badly burnt Delgado Master, I always assumed not for some reason though I don't *think* it was ever stated one way or t'other?”
If you count Big Finish canon, not only are Pratt and Beevers the same decaying Delgado incarnation, but
Spoiler
Originally Posted by Talma:
“Because Jacobi wouldn't have been able to do it otherwise, but he was fantastic for those few minutes. I loved John Simm's Master first time round, but Delgado was the first and best.”
“Because Jacobi wouldn't have been able to do it otherwise, but he was fantastic for those few minutes. I loved John Simm's Master first time round, but Delgado was the first and best.”
That makes sense, but I'd still like to have seen him play the role for more than a few minutes. They couldn't have him in a two parter at least so he could play the role of Yana in part 1, get revealed at the end and then spend a full episode in part 2 playing the Master? He didn't even get a full episode playing the character, just a few minutes!
"Die doctor! Die doctor! Muwuaahahahahahahahaha!"
^Based on this cartoonish performance alone I could never vote for Anthony Ainley.
As for that ravenous-chicken-eating, ham-acting, dress-wearing, head-shaking , irritating embarrassment John Simm, he should hand his head in shame!
Best Actor: Delgado
Best Actress: Gomez
Most Potential: Jacobi
^Based on this cartoonish performance alone I could never vote for Anthony Ainley.
As for that ravenous-chicken-eating, ham-acting, dress-wearing, head-shaking , irritating embarrassment John Simm, he should hand his head in shame!
Best Actor: Delgado
Best Actress: Gomez
Most Potential: Jacobi
Preferred John Simm in his first incarnation as the Master. Second story ruined him yet still pick him as a favourite. Michelle Gomez has the potential to be brilliant & looking forward to seeing how she plays out.
Originally Posted by Pink Knight:
“Everyone but Simm and Roberts. John Simm just didn't work for me as a character and Eric Roberts looked like he had stepped out of a trying too hard to look cool 80's American series e.g The Equilizer or the like.”
“Everyone but Simm and Roberts. John Simm just didn't work for me as a character and Eric Roberts looked like he had stepped out of a trying too hard to look cool 80's American series e.g The Equilizer or the like.”
That's a bit harsh. Edward Woodward was effortlessly cool.
Delgado and Gomez for me.
The first and the last (so far.)
Both playing the master, in a way that makes it feel like even though they are fighting the Doctor, they still don't really want to hurt him if they don't have too. Both just wanted their friend back.
The first and the last (so far.)
Both playing the master, in a way that makes it feel like even though they are fighting the Doctor, they still don't really want to hurt him if they don't have too. Both just wanted their friend back.
Originally Posted by CAMERA OBSCURA:
“Roger Delgado
Series 3 John Simm. - Probably the best 'Master' story imo. Turns out this incarnation was quite the nasty wife beater.
Michelle Gomez. - I'm really looking forward to seeing more after a rather brilliant debut, although slightly pushed to one side and rushed towards the end of DIH
Anthony Ainley
Derek Jacobi (short but wonderful)”
“Roger Delgado
Series 3 John Simm. - Probably the best 'Master' story imo. Turns out this incarnation was quite the nasty wife beater.
Michelle Gomez. - I'm really looking forward to seeing more after a rather brilliant debut, although slightly pushed to one side and rushed towards the end of DIH
Anthony Ainley
Derek Jacobi (short but wonderful)”
Too young for Roger Delgado but completely agree about John Simm and Derek Jacobi. The latter's performance was too shortlived.
Best
M
2 of 2
