Originally Posted by CARA2000:
“He mentioned Fleur because she is the only contestant this year that can justify his position, i.e. where his choreography is of any use (it hides the fact that she is an average singer).
Lola, Paul, Ben, Andrea are singers and don't need daft choreography to obscure a nice tone or a great voice.
Lauren needs a bit but she is not very good at it either.”
Fleur doesn't dance in order to "hide the fact that she is an average singer". She dances (while sings) because she's able to. She's an all-rounder and has the most star potential. You say "daft choreography" - I doubt any of the other acts could pull what she did off with 'Thriller' and 'All About That Bass'. Like it or not, she's the closest this year to having "The X Factor".
Originally Posted by Master Ozzy:
“Leona Lewis didn't crack America. She had one hit single over there (Bleeding Love) and a successful first album. Other than that, there hasn't really been anything. As for Ella, how can she have cracked America when she's only just released the song over there? My point is that this show ahs been on tv for 11 years...every year we get people coming out and saying so and so will crack America, but hardly anyone has done it. We've seen so many talented people on the show over 11 years, and only One Direction have managed to crack the U.S. It's ridiculous. With regards to Fleur, she's nothing special in the grand scheme of things...there's female's in the U.S who can do everything she can but a million times better.”
Regardless of where she is in the US charts these days, Leona HAS broken through in America - in a time pre-Adele where it was difficult for British artists to catch a break. Even last year Leona had many high-profile TV/live music events where she was performing in the States. She might not be the huge star in America she was in 2008 but she's still a household name.