Current X Factor contestant Fleur East made it to live shows back in 2005 as part of Addictiv Ladies. Which former group members would you like to see make a comeback? I think Derry Mansah from The Risk and and Matthew Protheroe from Futureproof (now perfoms under the name Vince Kidd) try out for X Factor again
Which group members would you like to see come back
1 of 2
Are we talking about the Vince Kidd on the voice UK...or a different one???..if so, can he even go on x factor now??...
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“Harry Styles would probably do well in the vote”
“Harry Styles would probably do well in the vote”
So would Zayn Malik, Liam Payne, Niall Horan and Louis Tomlinson.... Plz...they are too famous now...
PS: I'm embarrassed I know their names..
I guess they would only have people trying for a second shot that didn't find success the first time.
It would be interesting to see Anthony Hannah again, from Eton Road (or any of the Eton Road boys). They'd be Overs now
It would be interesting to see Anthony Hannah again, from Eton Road (or any of the Eton Road boys). They'd be Overs now
Originally Posted by darthdevidem01:
“The lead guy from Stereo Kicks LOL”
“The lead guy from Stereo Kicks LOL”
Not if they win................which is doubtful..
If I can pick anyone from a group who has made the live shows I would pick 2
1. Aston JLS
2. James SK (I will never ever know why they put him in a group he is an outstanding vocalist)
1. Aston JLS
2. James SK (I will never ever know why they put him in a group he is an outstanding vocalist)
Originally Posted by hannah:
“If I can pick anyone from a group who has made the live shows I would pick 2
1. Aston JLS
2. James SK (I will never ever know why they put him in a group he is an outstanding vocalist)”
“If I can pick anyone from a group who has made the live shows I would pick 2
1. Aston JLS
2. James SK (I will never ever know why they put him in a group he is an outstanding vocalist)”
Probably because without him...the group would not have any good singers...
Originally Posted by hannah:
“If I can pick anyone from a group who has made the live shows I would pick 2
1. Aston JLS
2. James SK (I will never ever know why they put him in a group he is an outstanding vocalist)”
“If I can pick anyone from a group who has made the live shows I would pick 2
1. Aston JLS
2. James SK (I will never ever know why they put him in a group he is an outstanding vocalist)”
I'd love to see Aston as a solo act, but he's already reached the Final and had a successful five years off the back of the show. I don't think he'd be allowed to enter again.
Originally Posted by Patti-Ann:
“I'd love to see Aston as a solo act, but he's already reached the Final and had a successful five years off the back of the show. I don't think he'd be allowed to enter again.”
“I'd love to see Aston as a solo act, but he's already reached the Final and had a successful five years off the back of the show. I don't think he'd be allowed to enter again.”
I know they are the only two from a group I like to see solo
Originally Posted by Kenneth_Chow:
“Probably because without him...the group would not have any good singers...”
“Probably because without him...the group would not have any good singers...”
I think there are some other good singers in SK but with James being there its all about James
Originally Posted by hannah:
“I think there are some other good singers in SK but with James being there its all about James”
“I think there are some other good singers in SK but with James being there its all about James”
There aren't any great singers other than James... The group would be a lot weaker...
Originally Posted by Kenneth_Chow:
“Are we talking about the Vince Kidd on the voice UK...or a different one???..if so, can he even go on x factor now??...”
“Are we talking about the Vince Kidd on the voice UK...or a different one???..if so, can he even go on x factor now??...”
Yes, I was referring to Vince Kidd from The Voice
Originally Posted by CalleighBoBo:
“Yes, I was referring to Vince Kidd from The Voice”
“Yes, I was referring to Vince Kidd from The Voice”
He was a top 4 finalist on the voice...would he even be allowed back...???
Originally Posted by Kenneth_Chow:
“He was a top 4 finalist on the voice...would he even be allowed back...???”
“He was a top 4 finalist on the voice...would he even be allowed back...???”
Why wouldn't he be?
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“Why wouldn't he be?”
“Why wouldn't he be?”
Because he was on the voice made the finale??...why else??...
Originally Posted by Kenneth_Chow:
“Because he was on the voice made the finale??...why else??...”
“Because he was on the voice made the finale??...why else??...”
It was a different show though - he wasn't a finalist on the x factor as a solo act.
Originally Posted by Kenneth_Chow:
“Because he was on the voice made the finale??...why else??...”
“Because he was on the voice made the finale??...why else??...”
Stephanie was a finalist on BGT, that didn't prevent her from auditioning. Unless he has a current record contract. he can enter the show. He could even turn up with Jessie J as his manager and still audition, should the producers think him good enough.
Originally Posted by LandslideBrad:
“Phoebe from Hope”
“Phoebe from Hope”
Defiantly! Never know why she got put in a band, her voice was amazing.
1 of 2
