• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
Argentine tango ballroom or Latin
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
edy10
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by Cal Christopher:
“I've always thought that the Argentine Tango, the Paso Doble the Charleston were ballroom dances. :O”

No. The Paso doble is one of the 5 Main Latin dances (jive, rumba, paso, chacha, samba).

The charleston and Argentine tango are NEITHER but both have a lot of Latin influence in some of the steps.
marinamau
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by An Thropologist:
“I know a lot of AT dancers and a few Argentinians (maybe 10 or thereabouts) all youngish 20's and 30's. There is no correlation with the sets. None of the Argentinians I know dance AT and all bar one have the attitude " What on earth do you want do that for?" or "Gosh you dance AT - my grandmother used to do that"

I tease them by saying when you want your culture back you will find it alive and well and living in the church halls of Europe.

Just one has been persuaded to come to classes. We do however have quite a few Chileans in our classes.”

The same with paso doble in Spain. No one bellow 70 years old will be dancing social Paso dobles. (Obviously not of the Ballroom variety, but what they dance on Verbenas in Spain.)
kaycee
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by apenny4them:
“Perhaps the first question to ask is - what makes any dance a Latin dance?”

Usually a Latin dance is one that has its roots in Latin America or Cuba, though of course Paso has its roots in Spain!

Generally when we - in the UK - talk about the ballroom or Latin dances, we are referring to the 10 dances used in Worldwide competitions, known as International style.
Ballroom (also called Modern) = waltz, tango (ballroom not AT), foxtrot, quickstep and Viennese Waltz.
Latin (correct name is Latin AND American) = chacha, samba, rumba, paso doble, jive.

In America, as well International style, they also dance :

American Smooth = waltz, tango, foxtrot & Viennese Waltz NO Quickstep.

Rhythm (Latin) = which as well as the 5 International Latin dances, which differ from the International style mainly in timing (eg: chacha is slower, rumba faster) but can also include salsa, mambo, bolero, any of the various swings etc.
kaycee
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by Cal Christopher:
“I've always thought that the Argentine Tango, the Paso Doble the Charleston were ballroom dances. :O”

You could say that all dances are danced in a ballroom, therefore they are ballroom dances!

PD is one of the 10 standard Latin dances.

Not all dances fall into the ballroom/Latin sections. AT falls into a section all its own, while Charleston, like things like the Lambeth Walk(!) are largely classed as Party Dances.
henrywilliams58
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by kaycee:
“ ..

PD is one of the 10 standard Latin dances.

.”


Originally Posted by kaycee:
“ ..

Rhythm (Latin) = which as well as the 5 International Latin dances, ... .”

Typo?

Is it 5 or 10 ? Or is there a difference between "standard" and "international" and is the latter a subset of the former?
henrywilliams58
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by marinamau:
“Out of all the ones I have met, only one! He was my uncle's brother in law, a gentleman in his late seventies then. He insisted that I danced with him. The simplest of milongas (i think it was, a few years ago). And he was wonderful, I had never danced AT before but he was an extraordinary lead, i instinctively knew what to do following him. So understated and powerful.”

Gosh. So inspiring and something to aspire to reach in my late 70s.
henrywilliams58
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by marinamau:
“The same with paso doble in Spain. No one bellow 70 years old will be dancing social Paso dobles. (Obviously not of the Ballroom variety, but what they dance on Verbenas in Spain.)”

But Sevillanas are quite common at weddings and verbenas. Great fun. Everybody joins in.

After a few well chilled Fino Sherries I can handle the zapateos (foot stamps) and palmeras (hand claps and thigh slaps) but struggle with the pivotes (pivots).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hst2SuN6Als

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJIUkpdXDDU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38TmYBfgNGM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EASDk_pLRIY
henrywilliams58
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by An Thropologist:
“I know a lot of AT dancers and a few Argentinians (maybe 10 or thereabouts) all youngish 20's and 30's. There is no correlation with the sets. None of the Argentinians I know dance AT and all bar one have the attitude " What on earth do you want do that for?" or "Gosh you dance AT - my grandmother used to do that"

I tease them by saying when you want your culture back you will find it alive and well and living in the church halls of Europe.

Just one has been persuaded to come to classes. We do however have quite a few Chileans in our classes.”

A couple of months ago I was chatting (in Spanish) to an Argentine woman at a milonga who had just danced with an Argentine bloke I know - husband of a visiting teacher. I smiled politely and sidled off when she said she was Argentine. Too intimidated. Turns out she is an improver / intermediate (like me) and we are now regular AT partners. She insists that I sing during the tanda. Happy to oblige if I know the song(s)
kaycee
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by henrywilliams58:
“Typo?

Is it 5 or 10 ? Or is there a difference between "standard" and "international" and is the latter a subset of the former?”

Not a typo, but I can see what is confusing.

"Ballroom" is at different times, confusingly, called Standard or Modern.

However, when people refer to the 10 standard dances that are danced in competition they mean the 5 standard Ballroom dances (W, FX, T, QS, VW) and the 5 standard Latin dances (CH, S, R, PD, J) as opposed to any other dances that might fall into those categories.

'International' is the style danced in the UK, the Continent, Australasia, Japan, Russia etc etc etc., and used in competition worldwide, as opposed to the American Style of dance i.e. Smooth (ballroom) and Rhythm (Latin). Should add they also dance the International style in America, particularly if they intend to compete outside US, which gives them the potential of a huge variety of dances to learn!

Hope this makes it a bit clearer?
henrywilliams58
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by kaycee:
“Not a typo, but I can see what is confusing.

"Ballroom" is at different times, confusingly, called Standard or Modern.

However, when people refer to the 10 standard dances that are danced in competition they mean the 5 standard Ballroom dances (W, FX, T, QS, VW) and the 5 standard Latin dances (CH, S, R, PD, J) as opposed to any other dances that might fall into those categories.

'International' is the style danced in the UK, the Continent, Australasia, Japan, Russia etc etc etc., and used in competition worldwide, as opposed to the American Style of dance i.e. Smooth (ballroom) and Rhythm (Latin). Should add they also dance the International style in America, particularly if they intend to compete outside US, which gives them the potential of a huge variety of dances to learn!

Hope this makes it a bit clearer?”

Ah yes. Thanks.
marinamau
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by henrywilliams58:
“Gosh. So inspiring and something to aspire to reach in my late 70s.”

It was one of those amazing moments that you don't forget. You will get there, you are pretty passionate about AT.
marinamau
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by henrywilliams58:
“But Sevillanas are quite common at weddings and verbenas. Great fun. Everybody joins in.

After a few well chilled Fino Sherries I can handle the zapateos (foot stamps) and palmeras (hand claps and thigh slaps) but struggle with the pivotes (pivots).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hst2SuN6Als

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJIUkpdXDDU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=38TmYBfgNGM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EASDk_pLRIY”

Sevillanas are traditional from Sevilla. It is danced as you say in the south of Spain (Andalusia) only, young and old alike. People from the south that have emigrated to the rest of Spain may continue their family tradition and other may learn it,though it is extremely rare that a public verbena in Leon or zaragoza for instance would have sevillanas. Never in Barcelona or Bilbao (but that is another story!). Each area in Spain has its own traditional regional dance, although arguably sevillanas are the most beautiful and striking.
A lot of people start with sevillanas on route for flamenco by the way, in fact sevillanas could be described as what the whites Andalusian dance in reply to the gypsies flamenco. Or even a "ballroom" version of flamenco, sevillanas have a very strict moves, flamenco is fire, freedom itself.

Last time I danced sevillanas was actually in sevilla at a private party of the wife of a bullfighter, a retired but very significant one. The way men dance in Spain! They go for it with gusto and ability too!
sofakat
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by An Thropologist:
“Good question. I am sure one of the international 10 experts will be able to answer.

My naīve take is that it is to do with origins. Most of the dances I consider to be Latin have an afro origin. So Salsa, Cha and Rumba are from Afro Cuban roots and I imagine Samba from Afro Brazilian Roots. I see them as coming from the street, working classes, slave classes etc.

But I think my theory falls apart when Jive gets added to the mix. That has a jazz origin doesn't it. Does that class as an afro root? And then doesn't Foxtrot have jazz connections too?

And then again the street dance upwards theory could also apply to Paso Doble and Tango too.

I am buggered if I know. ”

You're pretty close to the truth though!

Ballroom Jive comes from East Coast Swing (USA) and, like so many of the dances which fall under the 'Ballroom 10' label, their origins are from authentic dances - from Afro-Cuban son and salsa, rumba and mambo, USA swing, Samba from Brazil, Paso Doble from Spain and all altered quite significantly to fit in with the ballroom style.

Mambo and son escaped, happily!

So really much of ballroom dances are borrowed from the countries and bear very little resemblance to the original. In some cases they are unrecognisable

The Charleston is not a ballroom dance at all. It began in jazz clubs. Again, it was imported from the USA and underwent some changes when it hit the UK as a popular club dance after it was seen in Hollywood movies. Ditto the Foxtrot.

Argentine Tango does not belong in any ballroom category, nor could it be described as 'Latin'. That would be boxing it neatly under label to which it does not belong. If anything it belongs to Buenos Aires and Montevideo.
sofakat
18-11-2014
Originally Posted by apenny4them:
“Perhaps the first question to ask is - what makes any dance a Latin dance?”

Usually because it was 'borrowed' from a Latin country by the ballroom crowd who altered it to suit their brand of dancing.

Samba - from Brazil
Tango - from Argentina, but unrecognisable now in ballroom format
Jive - not Latin. It's American Swing - East Coast to be precise
Rumba - Cuba
Paso - Spain
sofakat
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by marinamau:
“Sevillanas are traditional from Sevilla. It is danced as you say in the south of Spain (Andalusia) only, young and old alike. People from the south that have emigrated to the rest of Spain may continue their family tradition and other may learn it,though it is extremely rare that a public verbena in Leon or zaragoza for instance would have sevillanas. Never in Barcelona or Bilbao (but that is another story!). Each area in Spain has its own traditional regional dance, although arguably sevillanas are the most beautiful and striking.
A lot of people start with sevillanas on route for flamenco by the way, in fact sevillanas could be described as what the whites Andalusian dance in reply to the gypsies flamenco. Or even a "ballroom" version of flamenco, sevillanas have a very strict moves, flamenco is fire, freedom itself.

Last time I danced sevillanas was actually in sevilla at a private party of the wife of a bullfighter, a retired but very significant one. The way men dance in Spain! They go for it with gusto and ability too!”

You are so right MM. Glad to see you post here and unravel the myths!

And it is so true about Sevillanas being the route to flamenco. That's how I did it myself - and ended up studying flamenco for many years.
henrywilliams58
19-11-2014
Is there a connection between Rumba Flamenca and Ballroom Rumba?
kaycee
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by henrywilliams58:
“Is there a connection between Rumba Flamenca and Ballroom Rumba?”

About the only connection between ballroom Rumba and Rumba Flamenca is the name rumba! There the similarity ends. Ballroom rumba originates from Cuba, while rumba Flamenca (or Flamenco rumba) originates in Spain; apart from the name there is no similarity at all.

At one time the term rhumba generally referred to Cuban type dances.

The ballroom version of rumba, along with cha cha, samba, paso, etc., were only developed with distinctive technique after the 2nd World War. They were mainly developed by Doris Lavelle and her partner Monsieur Pierre, who travelled extensively to study the dances in various countries.
henrywilliams58
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by kaycee:
“About the only connection between ballroom Rumba and Rumba Flamenca is the name rumba! There the similarity ends. Ballroom rumba originates from Cuba, while rumba Flamenca (or Flamenco rumba) originates in Spain; apart from the name there is no similarity at all.

At one time the term rhumba generally referred to Cuban type dances.

The ballroom version of rumba, along with cha cha, samba, paso, etc., were only developed with distinctive technique after the 2nd World War. They were mainly developed by Doris Lavelle and her partner Monsieur Pierre, who travelled extensively to study the dances in various countries.”

Thanks. Sometimes a little knowledge takes you backwards.
kaycee
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by henrywilliams58:
“Thanks. Sometimes a little knowledge takes you backwards.”

Oh dear, not sure what you mean??!!
henrywilliams58
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by kaycee:
“Oh dear, not sure what you mean??!!”

Rumba is not the same as Rumba
marinamau
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by kaycee:
“About the only connection between ballroom Rumba and Rumba Flamenca is the name rumba! There the similarity ends. Ballroom rumba originates from Cuba, while rumba Flamenca (or Flamenco rumba) originates in Spain; apart from the name there is no similarity at all.

At one time the term rhumba generally referred to Cuban type dances.

The ballroom version of rumba, along with cha cha, samba, paso, etc., were only developed with distinctive technique after the 2nd World War. They were mainly developed by Doris Lavelle and her partner Monsieur Pierre, who travelled extensively to study the dances in various countries.”

Actually, rumba flamenca is a dance considered de Ida y Vuelta. It means that is the result of Spanish emigration to Cuba and then returned to Spain, so in fact it does have some commonality. It is one of the more melosa (subtle, sensual...) form of flamenco, influence no doubt of the Cubans.
Then there is the rumba Catalana which I think has less to do with Cuba and it is generally a more modern occurrence, Peret being the "king". Basically, it's a sound created by gypsy immigrants in Cataluņa, very party like, almost gypsy kings.
marinamau
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by sofakat:
“You are so right MM. Glad to see you post here and unravel the myths!

And it is so true about Sevillanas being the route to flamenco. That's how I did it myself - and ended up studying flamenco for many years.”

Me too! Everyone can learn and dance sevillanas, real flamenco not so many.
People either have angel or not, and no matter how many hours they put in, if they lack it, there is nothing they can do about it.
An Thropologist
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by marinamau:
“Me too! Everyone can learn and dance sevillanas, real flamenco not so many.
People either have angel or not, and no matter how many hours they put in, if they lack it, there is nothing they can do about it.”

Interesting stuff MM Thank you. What is angel? Something like duende?
TerryM22
19-11-2014
Originally Posted by An Thropologist:
“Interesting stuff MM Thank you. What is angel? Something like duende?”

I was wondering that too
marinamau
21-11-2014
Originally Posted by An Thropologist:
“Interesting stuff MM Thank you. What is angel? Something like duende?”

Yes, it is Similar. Some sugest that duende is a more profund aspect and angel is more superficial, yet both relate to innate grace and ability to embody music and transmit certain magic, also the ability to dance with no choreography and in the moment. That Je ne se quais that diferenciates a good technician to a great dancer.
As everything in flamenco, it is fairly misterious and undefined.
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map