Favourite
1. Dannii Minogue
2. Sharon Osbourne
3. Nicole Sherzinger
4. SImon Cowell
5. Mel B
6. Louis Walsh
7. Cheryl Cole
8. Tulisa
9. Kelly Rowland
10. Gary Barlow
Least favourite

I wasn't expecting to like Dannii, but she's turned out to be the only judge I've ever liked.
I'm gonna struggle with the rest, but here goes ...

1. Dannii

*huge gap*

2. Nicole
3. Tulisa

4. Gary

5. Kelly

6. Mel
7. Simon
8. Cheryl

*huge gap*

9. Sharon
10. Louis

Favourite
1. Dannii Minogue
2. Mel B
3. Sharon Osbourne
4. Simon Cowell
5. Cheryl Cole
6. Louis Walsh
7. Nicole Sherzinger
8. Kelly Rowland
9. Tulisa
10. Gary Barlow
Least favourite

Ok guys so I have decided to extend the voting until Sunday night at 6pm! We keep getting so many replies and the order keep changing!

So, to confirm. Voting closes at 6pm, Sunday night.

1 Nicole Scherzinger
2 Sharon Osbourne
3 Dannii Minogue
4 Tulisa
5 Simon Cowell
6 Mel B
7 Louis Walsh
8 Gary Barlow
9 Cheryl Cole
10 Kelly Rowland

Still baffled at this forum's obsession with Dannii. In my opinion she added absolutely nothing to the show. The most bland, pointless and forgettable judge there has ever been.

1 Nicole sherzinger
2 Gary Barlow
3 Simon Cowell
4 Sharon Osbourne
5 Louis Walsh
5 Danni Minogue
6 Kelly Rowland
7 Mel B
8 Tulisa
9 Cheryl Cole

1. Nicole
2. Tulisa
3. Gary
4. Louis
5. Mel B
6. Cheryl
7. Sharon
8.Dannii
9. Kelly
10. Simon

She gave real constructive criticism, rised above the bullshit from the other judges and was always classy.

Top 3 keep changing still. The other are all nearly on par with each other. Don't mean to sound like a broken record but literally every vote changes things!

And with that was incredibly boring and dull.

Remember, voting is now open until Sunday. Closes at 6pm

Favourite
1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Dannii Minogue
3. Kelly Rowland
4. Gary Barlow
5. Tulisa
6. Simon Cowell
7. Louis Walsh
8. Cheryl Cole
9. Mel B
10. Sharon Osbourne
Least Favourite

True & (previous poster) I take it you don't watch XFAUS or else I doubt you'd still be calling her classy after her recent downfall of petty comments towards Reigan...

1. Cheryl Cole (Favourite)
2. Simon Cowell
3. Gary Barlow
4. Sharon Osbourne
5. Louis Walsh
6. Mel B
7. Dannii Minogue
8. Kelly Rowland
9. Tulisa
10. Nicole Scherzinger (Least favourite)

I only really like Cheryl, Simon and Gary. The rest could have been in any order.

Struggling with where to put Simon on this - the Simon of this year would be way lower than the Simon of early years. Similar with Sharon too - individually she wasn't as good last year as originally but as a panel the four worked last year far better than the four this year.

There is also the duel aspect of them being a judge and a mentor - Mel B for example is a brilliant judge but seems to be a pretty rubbish mentor.

1. Nicole Scherzinger
2. Dannii Minouge
3. Gary Barlow
4. Simon Cowell
5. Mel B
6. Kelly Rowland
7. Tulisa
8. Sharon Osbourne
9. Cheryl Cole
10. Louis Walsh

And picking a dream panel of judges I think I'd go for Gary, Nicole, Simon and Mel B.

1. Tulisa
2. Simon
3. Cheryl
4. Nicole
5. Mel B
6. Dannii
7. Sharon
8. Louis
9. Kelly
10. Gary

I've watched all of XFUS and all of XFAUS except for the first season. She had quite a good point about Reigan, she was doing big pop numbers with huge production when performances like Dog Days Are Over and Burn For You was more her as an artist. I think it got taken over the top but Redfoo wasn't completely innocent in the matter himself.

I've found her more interesting than any of the other judges. If this was a vote before this season I wouldn't have raided Cheryl so highly as she was the queen of dull beforehand.

To further add, if you watched XFUS and I'm not going to assume that you have or haven't, then Nicole and Kelly changed far more in terms of personality than Dannii ever has.

You have voted Louis Walsh as your number one, a judge that says the same stuff over and over again. Someone who clearly doesn't care about his acts and will do anything that the producers ask of him. He is also responsible for the dire dated theme weeks we've had such as Queen VS. Michael Jackson which we met with the producers about.

FAVOURITE

Mel B
Kelly
Nicole
Gary
Dannii
Louis
Sharon (loved her in the first few years. Thought she was horrendous last year)
Tulisa
Cheryl
Simon

LEAST FAVOURITE

1. Dannii Minogue
2. Mel B
3. Nicole Scherzinger
4. Tulisa
5. Cheryl Cole
6. Simon Cowell
7. Louis Walsh
8. Gary Barlow
9. Kelly Rowland
10. Sharon Osbourne

She was really rude and obnoxious seems to be the general opinion of her Reigan rivalry but if you already like her I guess your opinion won't be changed.

I did watch XFUSA and I do agree that Nicole and Kelly were different on our show; Nicole seemed to fit in over here and Kelly vice versa. I tried to base it on how they were like over here though.

Lol I don't think Louis is the BEST judge but he adds a type of humour to the show that I'd really miss if he wasn't there. He's kind of adorable too.

1. Dannii Minogue
2. Nicole Scherzinger
3. Simon Cowell
4. Kelly Rowlamd
5. Sharon Osbourne
6. Mel B
7. Louis Walsh
8. Gary Borelow
9. Tulisa
10. Biffa Marryafrenchmanforpromo

Mel B isn't a brilliant judge at all. She just follows the awfully bland and predictable script. She didn't even acknowledge Paul's performance in the sing-off a couple of weeks ago.

1. Louis
2.Sharon
3.Cheryl
4.Nicole
5.Simon
6.Dannii
7.Tulisa
8.Mel
9.Kelly
10.Gary