You have to remember that it is the X Factor producers that you are talking about here, and they are not the brightest sparks on the planet.

Jesus. You're reading far too much into it. We don't even know if Andrea is gay. Also I'm gay so I guess I'm insulting myself too?

You're a self hating gay...

Yawn after this I never wanna hear a Whitney song again /:

Unless its Whitney singing it...

Not at all. I'm very at ease with myself and couldn't care less if some random on an internet forum made a lame quip about a bearded contestant on a tv talent show (who may or may not be gay) singing a song about being 'every woman'.

Besides, there's so many problems with you considering being 'womanly' insulting I wouldn't even know where to start.

Looking forward to Fleur and Ben (really intriguing song choice).

As for the rest: yawn.

You are the one that started it...when you implied Andrea is...I didn't say it was wrong...Im just slightly insulted that you are slotting Andrea in that womanly box by saying he should sing I'm every woman..probably because he's gay...

I agree with that

He has a beard. He's clearly not a woman. That is why it would be amusing to me. That is all. Somehow you extrapolated that to be based upon his sexuality which we know nothing about.

Well...you clearly should know how your comment sounds to others... Just saying..because the same can be said for Ben and Stevi singing it...the fact that you picked Andrea makes this sounds like it does...

Stevi's choice = "We want you out"....
I'd rather Andrea did Something About the Way you Look Tonight rather than one of the groups.

I don't... know... why... you.... type like... this?

Geez, calm down on the ellipsis. And it was a joke since gay people are generally stereotyped as being effeminate. And it makes sense since Andrea is constantly being portrayed as a "diva" (from the judges words not mine) whereas Stevi and Ben haven't. That's it. Even I found it a little funny and I'm gay too. :\

Where's where with ...

Dots are the ways I seperate my phrases...I'm not going to stop


... ... ... ...

And stereotypes isn't funny...

I've just checked on YouTube - Journey South, Stacey, One Direction and Luke all did it Recycled and recycled again

I know Andrea will sing wonderfully, but I really wanted him to do The Circle of Life, as he's already sung Whitney twice.

So far you're the only person who's taken issue with it. You've added your own assumptions and insinuation to the comment I made and are leaping to conclusions that it's about sexuality when I said nothing about sexuality, supposed or otherwise. Andrea's sexuality, whatever it is, might be high in your thoughts but it's not in mine.

Have you seen some women

Hmm - REALLY not sure about Ben's choice.

Yeah I went 'WHHHHHAAAAAT??' when I just read it 5 mins ago.

However, Simon isn't stupid. I reckon he knows he can take the risk with Ben because of his popularity. If he pulls it off.. then it will be that 'turning point' for the winner. If he fails, I still think there is plenty flexibility in the vote to continue through..

Lets see. It's an odd choice but maybe it will be 'that moment' for Ben.

I don't see how that song can be twisted to fit him...

I think Ben or Fleur will win at this point so i wouldn't worry too much over his song choice.

What you think and reality could be very different... Ben might not be doing as well as we think, we dont know that...let's not assume anything..

Yeah I am struggling a little too and love Ben's voice. Really not sure about it. But you never know. We might just be surprised and we sorely need to have an 'interesting' moment on the show anyway..

I smell another sssssllllooooowwwweeeedddd dddddoooowwwwnnnnnn rendition from Lauren.
Can't imagine her signing How Will I Know at the same tempo as Whitney.