Why do you watch XFactor and what does it mean to you?
![[Deleted User]](https://w0.vanillicon.com/v2/08ce5bab8ae7b1f0073fdcf2efe96d53.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 562 Forum Member
✭✭
It's becoming more and more apparent every year that a significant portion of XFactor viewers now see the show as a bit of a joke at best, a manipulative lie at worst. This year I think the forum has become even more divisive in terms of which camp forumites are a part of.
It seems that every thread now contains the fundamental argument of whether the show is what it perhaps initially started as and still pertains to be (a singing contest) or whether it is a cynical tool to line Simon Cowell's pockets. The number veering more towards the latter on the sliding scale, seems to be increasing at a very fast rate, especially with Cowell now back on the panel, the Paul Akister incident and release of Steve Brookstein's book.
So what I wondered is, where do you stand? Why do you watch the XFactor? What does it mean to you? The options in the poll won't cover everyone's exact feelings but please choose the answer that most closely represents your viewpoint.
It seems that every thread now contains the fundamental argument of whether the show is what it perhaps initially started as and still pertains to be (a singing contest) or whether it is a cynical tool to line Simon Cowell's pockets. The number veering more towards the latter on the sliding scale, seems to be increasing at a very fast rate, especially with Cowell now back on the panel, the Paul Akister incident and release of Steve Brookstein's book.
So what I wondered is, where do you stand? Why do you watch the XFactor? What does it mean to you? The options in the poll won't cover everyone's exact feelings but please choose the answer that most closely represents your viewpoint.
Why do you watch XFactor and what does it mean to you? 67 votes
It's an entertainment show, I just watch for a laugh and don't think deeply about it
22%
15 votes
It's manipulated, scripted, predictable but I still enjoy watching the drama unfold
28%
19 votes
It's a singing contest and I watch to see real talent who can go on to sell records
5%
4 votes
It's about finding potential stars who can go on to perform for a living and entertain the public
16%
11 votes
It's a disgusting show that manipulates viewers, toys with contestants & ruins music industry
26%
18 votes
0
Comments
Plus I actually really enjoy the discussion on here. Not going to lie, that's kind of become a part of why I still bother to be honest.
I suppose my closest answer to the ones on the poll is the top one. I'm aware of the manipulation and the less favourable aspects of the show, but in all honestly, I don't really care. It's just something to do on a Saturday/Sunday night.
It is a talent show, but it isn't The Voice so I do like to see performers and those who entertain me - not necessarily the best vocalists. That said, I always hate the novelty acts with the exception of Stevi who I didn't mind. For example, Fleur is an amazing all round popstar with a decent voice, Andrea has a knockout voice but is quite boring. I can't claim that I don't take it a bit too seriously at times though; I often play the talent card and call a fix when a fave of mine is eliminated haha.
Plus, occasionally someone does a decent job with a song. You do get some decent singers here and there.
If it was on in June/July, hardly anyone would bother with it
Occasionally there's an act one really likes as is the case with me this year right from the off, so have watched it fully this year so far.
I am however finding the hype/manipulation/derailing of the various contestants hard to stomach, making it very unlikely I will ever watch the show again beyond my act...
Its all about who Simon wants to make plenty money off....but eventually unbeknown to the winner, they are more likely to crash and burn a few years down the line. ..ask Leona and Steve B!!!
'Why do you watch X factor'?
It's a disgusting show that manipulates viewers, toys with contestants & ruins music industry
Is that really why you watch
I clicked no 4 - about people going on to have career in entertainment.
Good point raised here!!! Lol:D:D
They may not enjoy watching it, but a show which blatantly points out who they want out each week and who they want to win overall is a great way to "win" free money.
So I guess a mix of 2 & 4 for me.
Ah but it does make sense in the context of this forum!
I added this option because I've seen dozens of posts on here from people saying they hate the show and everything it represents, that's it's a complete joke, that everyone who votes is wasting money, that they need to wake up and see what is going on..............but they are obviously still watching!
As someone has already commented in this thread, some people watch because they find it cathartic to shout at the TV!
Admittedly, this option could maybe do with a second part to explain why they watch (there are two parts to the question) but in all honesty, I didn't know why someone would watch if they felt that strongly about it, so didn't have anything to write!
Agreed, I only watch the live shows for the betting now (after I realised how manipulated it was a few years back!) though I do quite enjoy pre-live shows. But "betting" is a pretty boring answer. I wanted to know what the real fans/watchers of the show think.
For the record, I selected number 2 but am rapidly becoming a 5!
I'd better abstain.