I know it's a moot point and hypothetical... but from the little we saw of CC, I think he might have given Foggy a run for his money. He was coming across really well.

I hope they ask him back next year if he's up for it, it would be good to see him be able to give the whole series a go.

Discuss...

A lot seem to think that he would have won, but we simply don't know he'd have reacted to different things along the way. I think he'd have certainly been there to the end, but who knows...

...it would be nice if he came back at some point, but that in part depends on how strongly he now associates his experience with the loss of his brother...

...and if he did come back, would he gain extra votes because of what has happened, and would that be fair to others taking part?

Hard to say really, but Foggy is a great winner

I think it's likely Craig would have won, unless he ended up doing or saying something that didn't go across well with the general viewer (which I doubt). He came across very well in his short stay.

Top three material, for sure. But Foggy is a deserving winner.

Who can say,Foggy was top of the pile all the way through.

I do think the series suffered from losing Craig so soon though.

I think Craig would have won.

Hard to say really! If him and Foggy were the last two standing, I don't think there would have been many votes between them, kind of like when it was between Charlie and Ashley.

I also think if Jimmy didn't ''bully'' jake he would be a contender and Craig also

That was going to be my answer, although I never thought Jimmy bullied Jake, I think it could possibly have between those 3.

Im not sure how far Jimmy could have gone. Yes the 'bullying' incident probably lost him a lot of votes but he was a bit of a wuss at the trials and he was quite annoying. After last nights programme, it is clear that he is an attention seeker and I think the viewers would have soon got fed up with it if we had seen it night after night.

I loved Craig but its difficult to say that he would have won without him having the full experience. Hope he feels he can do it next year if he is invited. The producers would be mad not to give him the chance.

I also Dont think Jimmy bulled Jake it was just banter

We will never know. How long is a piece of elastic..??

Craig has a big fan base - red dwarf, corrie and robot wars (!) plus seemed a nice guy so I would think he'd have been in the final three, but not sure of the demographic who actually vote - maybe not red dwarf fans??

Jimmy was never in contention, he was far too annoying to go very far. Marmite characters can do well, but I'm not sure enough liked him to even consider him Marmite... and that was before the bantaaaah. He just tried too hard to be funny, and constantly looked for assurance that he was. Total nobjob!

Prob would of made final 3 but I still think foggy would of won, people tend to clammer for things they can't have so alot of people are naturally feeling like Craig would of won purely because its a change on what actually happened, we have no idea if he'd of reacted well got favorable editing etc so I really think its tough to say but I'd say maybe if he was still in the top 3 would of been 1. Foggy 2. Craig 3.Mel

Its good to note that a person has a big fan base as opposed to Twitter followers. Completely different..

Keshi Heads (fans of Takeshi's Castle) might have done

But many people thought he did so he wasn't a contender. You could say what if or what not to all of them I am sure at some point so it is pointless to say "if this".

And similarly with Craig - I liked him a lot in the short time he was there but anything could have happened as the series went on and don't forget people are very fickle.

Something like "For f**k's sake, Bullard - just shut up for a bit"?

Agreed

Red Dwarf would of had it in the bag, massive following.