Originally Posted by madiain28:
“I agree with your quote until you put the real musician comment in.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Musician
A musician (or instrumentalist) is a person who plays a musical instrument or is musically talented, or one who composes, conducts, or performs music.
Prior to Madonna becoming a solo artist she was a drummer in two bands, She has also learned to play guitar. So I think that qualifies her as a musician, you may not like her music or think she is a good musician but she is a real musician.
”
It was aimed in a live show sense...Madonna maybe a musician, but the show/spectacular takes away from the craft, even Prince's lovesexy show though it was a great spectacle the craft was lost in it...a stripped down set with just the artist and band. Some like one or the other and some like both, personally I prefer the stripped down set, so nothing distracts from the skills of the artist and band...and more importantly no miming, which is my pet hate if you are doing a live show...may as well just listen to the album.
I don't mind Madonna, have seen her twice live, one good and one bad show...though I wouldn't go and see her now, I do think she is probably one artist if you ever get the chance to see live then you should, like her music or not....lets face it I think everybody will like at least one of her songs, even if they wouldn't admit it.