Paul followed by Andrea followed by, well, no-one really. The rest all had very casual relationships with pitch and if you can't get the most basic fundamental aspect of singing right then you're not a very good singer in my book, as agreeable as your natural tone might be.
So.. Who really had the best voice this year?
2 of 2
Paul by far had the best voice no one else apart from Andrea was vocally in the same league as him THAT'S A FACT
Originally Posted by sali9362:
“Paul by far had the best voice no one else apart from Andrea was vocally in the same league as him THAT'S A FACT”
“Paul by far had the best voice no one else apart from Andrea was vocally in the same league as him THAT'S A FACT”
it really isn't , even in CAPS its still just an opinion
Andrea, Lauren, Paul. Not quite sure why they didn't allow Paul to get further, and surprised that they seemed to deliberately de-rail Lauren. In fact, I thought Lauren was the most marketable right from the start but they clearly wanted her out after about week 4.
Although, regarding Paul, If the radio was on in the background and the contestants were signing on it, I think I would only recognise Andrea's or Lauren's voice.
Although, regarding Paul, If the radio was on in the background and the contestants were signing on it, I think I would only recognise Andrea's or Lauren's voice.
Originally Posted by mimik1uk:
“it really isn't , even in CAPS its still just an opinion”
“it really isn't , even in CAPS its still just an opinion
”
LOL i am not being serious i am just expressing a strong opinion of who i thought had the best voice - no one else has to agree with me
Im going to be contraversial and say monica micheal she would of won but cheryl to a dislike to here which i reckon was look based
Originally Posted by sali9362:
“Uuuuummmmm.........Who the hell is that?”
“Uuuuummmmm.........Who the hell is that?”
Former Champions League winning Liverpool manager, gave a massive press conference years ago in which he said "FACT" about 100 times. Seeing people declaring something to be FACT always reminds me of him.
Originally Posted by Felix-:
“Andrea had the best raw voice. Paul and Lauren had better control than him. I also think we shouldn't forget James Graham from Stereo Kicks - whatever I may have thought about the group, he was always excellent vocally.”
“Andrea had the best raw voice. Paul and Lauren had better control than him. I also think we shouldn't forget James Graham from Stereo Kicks - whatever I may have thought about the group, he was always excellent vocally.”
This is exactly what I was thinking - he was wasted in that group and I don't understand why he didn't go through as a soloist ahead of Jake and Jack, who were both very limited. Presumably it was all related to looks as he didn't fit the look for the fit young male category. Which is a bit daft seeing as Jake was criticised for focusing on his looks rather than his music.
Also a mention for Kerrianne who was light years ahead of all of this year's girls. Not putting her through was a ridiculous decision from Cheryl or whoever pulls her strings. The girls' category looked so strong at the judges' houses stage.
I think this was a year with some very very weak singers, more so than in previous years. Jake, Jack, Jay, Steph and the dark girl in OTY in particular were very poor and inconsistent. Then you have your joke acts in Stevi and Blonde Electric and there's not a lot left.
No wonder people like Fleur. She might not be a powerhouse singer like Andrea but her performance more than made up for any slight vocal inadequacies. The majority were so weak I don't think I'd have put them through Boot Camp.
Paul and Andrea were in a different league. Ben given the right songs was good but Paul and Andrea proved they could sing anything and do a great job. Some of the contestants who made it as far as judges houses were also better singers than some who made it to the lives.
Originally Posted by Patti-Ann:
“I agree - Paul and Andrea the best two vocalists and Fleur the best stage performer
They kept giving the big diva ballads - a few up tempo could have made all the difference
Look how good he was with Ella in the duet”
“I agree - Paul and Andrea the best two vocalists and Fleur the best stage performer
They kept giving the big diva ballads - a few up tempo could have made all the difference
Look how good he was with Ella in the duet
”
I agree ANDREA was my winner he absolutely outsung both Ben and Fleur on Saturday night.
Originally Posted by lulu g:
“BIB - You're right. He carried them single-handedly. He really should have been put through as a solo singer instead of Jake, or that other one, who was the wild card.”
“BIB - You're right. He carried them single-handedly. He really should have been put through as a solo singer instead of Jake, or that other one, who was the wild card.”
Yes I agree, hopefully James will be approached and be given a record deal as a solo artist.
Originally Posted by dia6olo:
“Lord Sugar has it right!
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 2h 2 hours ago
.@King39Niamh the Italian should have won he had a voice , and oh by the way its a singing competition not a male hunk model show
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 2h 2 hours ago
What's the point of judges on X-Factor when the public decide.The winner was voted by the public for his looks not his voice. Total joke!
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 4h 4 hours ago
Ben is rubbish compared to Andrea fact . 2 a penny pub singer
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 4h 4 hours ago
They are asking judges highlight of the year on X-Factor . I think it was Cheryl's mascara running all the time with her crocodile tears
LOL”
“Lord Sugar has it right!
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 2h 2 hours ago
.@King39Niamh the Italian should have won he had a voice , and oh by the way its a singing competition not a male hunk model show
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 2h 2 hours ago
What's the point of judges on X-Factor when the public decide.The winner was voted by the public for his looks not his voice. Total joke!
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 4h 4 hours ago
Ben is rubbish compared to Andrea fact . 2 a penny pub singer
Lord Sugar @Lord_Sugar · 4h 4 hours ago
They are asking judges highlight of the year on X-Factor . I think it was Cheryl's mascara running all the time with her crocodile tears
LOL
”
Totally agree with Alan Sugar the REAL WINNER of the show left on Saturday night.
2 of 2
