Posts in this thread really show what is wrong with the show. Anyone a bit different doesn't stand a bloody chance on X Factor. She's not rubbish at all. She was in a talent show for 2 weeks, given crap song choices and ridiucled by the judges, and from that everyone concludes that she's rubbish. I mean, if X Factor says she's rubbish then she must be rubbish!! Seriously, come on! She was let down because they didn't have a clue what on earth to do with her. Anyone who is different, a bit unique, interesting, has a bit of spark...the show just wipes them out.
Stephanie Nala can make it big IMO
2 of 2
I thought she had the weakest voice of all the girls. Listen to the final 16's song last night. Her voice sounds quite babyish - it's not a nice tone IMO. Lauren has a much much more pleasant voice to listen to. I think Kerrianne and Emily also had better voices.
If the show had got behind her definitely 
I wasn't a fan of the reggae thing she was given though, I don't think Steph was particularly keen either
I wasn't a fan of the reggae thing she was given though, I don't think Steph was particularly keen either
Originally Posted by Master Ozzy:
“Posts in this thread really show what is wrong with the show. Anyone a bit different doesn't stand a bloody chance on X Factor. She's not rubbish at all. She was in a talent show for 2 weeks, given crap song choices and ridiucled by the judges, and from that everyone concludes that she's rubbish. I mean, if X Factor says she's rubbish then she must be rubbish!! Seriously, come on! She was let down because they didn't have a clue what on earth to do with her. Anyone who is different, a bit unique, interesting, has a bit of spark...the show just wipes them out.”
“Posts in this thread really show what is wrong with the show. Anyone a bit different doesn't stand a bloody chance on X Factor. She's not rubbish at all. She was in a talent show for 2 weeks, given crap song choices and ridiucled by the judges, and from that everyone concludes that she's rubbish. I mean, if X Factor says she's rubbish then she must be rubbish!! Seriously, come on! She was let down because they didn't have a clue what on earth to do with her. Anyone who is different, a bit unique, interesting, has a bit of spark...the show just wipes them out.”
sorry but she had one of the weakest voices ever , she made abi alton from last year look like a power ballad singer
I have heard people running their nails down a blackboard that sounded more pleasant than listening to her sing
Originally Posted by mimik1uk:
“sorry but she had one of the weakest voices ever , she made abi alton from last year look like a power ballad singer
I have heard people running their nails down a blackboard that sounded more pleasant than listening to her sing”
“sorry but she had one of the weakest voices ever , she made abi alton from last year look like a power ballad singer
I have heard people running their nails down a blackboard that sounded more pleasant than listening to her sing”
This post sums up the typical XF viewer.
Originally Posted by jerefprdterra:
“This post sums up the typical XF viewer.”
“This post sums up the typical XF viewer.”
coming from you and the accuracy of your comments i'll take that as a compliment
there were acts on the show I didn't particularly like but I could understand why other people might
not with steph , she had one of the most irritating voices I have ever heard
I thought she was over rated if anything.
I found her voice very child-like and also quite weak.
She seemd nice enough, but not my cup of tea.
I found her voice very child-like and also quite weak.
She seemd nice enough, but not my cup of tea.
Originally Posted by scratchy23:
“She stole the show? Andrea is similar to her? LOL what the hell have you been watching?
She has a weak, irritating voice and about as much charisma as a brick wall - there's a reason why she found herself in the bottom three two weeks running and that's cos she's shit. She is one of my most hated X Factor acts of all time. Utterly despicable.”
“She stole the show? Andrea is similar to her? LOL what the hell have you been watching?
She has a weak, irritating voice and about as much charisma as a brick wall - there's a reason why she found herself in the bottom three two weeks running and that's cos she's shit. She is one of my most hated X Factor acts of all time. Utterly despicable.”
Quite strong feelings there.
Do you really hate her more than Overload Generation who were quite honestly horrific in their sing off?
Originally Posted by Liam_Westfield:
“Was just watching some stuff from week 1 and 2 and she was underrated. She obviously struggled on her own but she wasn't helped by the pimping of Andrea who is a similar artist to her, and thus her poor performance stood out like a sore thumb.
In the final when she had her solo she stole the show. Maybe she should audition again next year ?”
“Was just watching some stuff from week 1 and 2 and she was underrated. She obviously struggled on her own but she wasn't helped by the pimping of Andrea who is a similar artist to her, and thus her poor performance stood out like a sore thumb.
In the final when she had her solo she stole the show. Maybe she should audition again next year ?”
How on earth were Stephanie and Andrea similar
Is this thread a wind up
Originally Posted by Master Ozzy:
“Posts in this thread really show what is wrong with the show. Anyone a bit different doesn't stand a bloody chance on X Factor. She's not rubbish at all. She was in a talent show for 2 weeks, given crap song choices and ridiucled by the judges, and from that everyone concludes that she's rubbish. I mean, if X Factor says she's rubbish then she must be rubbish!! Seriously, come on! She was let down because they didn't have a clue what on earth to do with her. Anyone who is different, a bit unique, interesting, has a bit of spark...the show just wipes them out.”
“Posts in this thread really show what is wrong with the show. Anyone a bit different doesn't stand a bloody chance on X Factor. She's not rubbish at all. She was in a talent show for 2 weeks, given crap song choices and ridiucled by the judges, and from that everyone concludes that she's rubbish. I mean, if X Factor says she's rubbish then she must be rubbish!! Seriously, come on! She was let down because they didn't have a clue what on earth to do with her. Anyone who is different, a bit unique, interesting, has a bit of spark...the show just wipes them out.”
A bit of spark? That's the one thing I felt she didn't have.
She had a better voice than she was given credit for, but she was too nervous and bland to make any impression. And Cheryl can't be blamed for that.
Was she the one caught peeing outside Marks & Spencers? Her YouTube covers are quite nice but she wasn't made for the big stage, at least not as a soloist. She seemed lost, and her voice was weak. I can see her doing well as a very niche artist, but she has a lot of work to do first.
Originally Posted by JavarnJohnson:
“Was she the one caught peeing outside Marks & Spencers? Her YouTube covers are quite nice but she wasn't made for the big stage, at least not as a soloist. She seemed lost, and her voice was weak. I can see her doing well as a very niche artist, but she has a lot of work to do first.”
“Was she the one caught peeing outside Marks & Spencers? Her YouTube covers are quite nice but she wasn't made for the big stage, at least not as a soloist. She seemed lost, and her voice was weak. I can see her doing well as a very niche artist, but she has a lot of work to do first.”
Peeing outside M&S, bullying allegations from ex-schoolmates - even her Lorraine interview was interrupted by a fire alarm. Didn't have the best of luck on the show, poor Steph
Originally Posted by scratchy23:
“She stole the show? Andrea is similar to her? LOL what the hell have you been watching?
She has a weak, irritating voice and about as much charisma as a brick wall - there's a reason why she found herself in the bottom three two weeks running and that's cos she's shit. She is one of my most hated X Factor acts of all time. Utterly despicable.”
“She stole the show? Andrea is similar to her? LOL what the hell have you been watching?
She has a weak, irritating voice and about as much charisma as a brick wall - there's a reason why she found herself in the bottom three two weeks running and that's cos she's shit. She is one of my most hated X Factor acts of all time. Utterly despicable.”
Wow. If you feel so strongly about someone you have never met in your life and quite frankly never did anything wrong I suggest you need councilling
Originally Posted by Arthur_B:
“Peeing outside M&S, bullying allegations from ex-schoolmates - even her Lorraine interview was interrupted by a fire alarm. Didn't have the best of luck on the show, poor Steph”
“Peeing outside M&S, bullying allegations from ex-schoolmates - even her Lorraine interview was interrupted by a fire alarm. Didn't have the best of luck on the show, poor Steph”
Poor girl couldn't catch a break..
Steph was treated really unfairly in my opinion. I loved all her auditions and loved them - she was so calming and captivating but as soon as I saw that she was billed as "unemployed" as the tag under her name I knew she wouldn't be going far. She was heavily rumoured to be going through to the live shows but I am amazed she got as far as week two. We'd seen all of thirty seconds of her in screen time before she went into the live shows, she was used as the catapult for Lola not going through into the live shows so most people automatically hated her because of that. Add to that her being given one relatively unknown reggae-lite song with bad staging and her first week in the bottom two was no surprise. Week two, she was given a popular song but in a similar arrangement to week one, followed straight away by Andrea who caused everyone to forget her especially as he used the same setpieces as her but in a more appealing way. After all this, she was out straight away and Simon even had the cheek to say "Steph didn't believe she could win" - I wonder why after all of that?!?! Add to that the leaked bullying stories and you have a recipe for disaster.
Poor thing. She should have stayed with Luminites, she was so likeable with them and they were a great band. I do think she has a chance to be successful but it will be hard for her to be taken seriously after this stint.
Poor thing. She should have stayed with Luminites, she was so likeable with them and they were a great band. I do think she has a chance to be successful but it will be hard for her to be taken seriously after this stint.
2 of 2
