• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Early Figures for Christmas Number 1
<<
<
3 of 7
>>
>
IsThisHappiness
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“You can be smug now, - i am not having a meltdown why would i its XF, im just saying votes dont make winners. go and speak to the other male winners who won and where are they now???

I was voting for her I wanted her in the final, I would VOTE for my favourite but winning wasnt ever going to happen for Fleur.”

But why say you never wanted her to win when you've posted thousands of time in the last few weeks saying you did?

Why lie to create a point? It doesn't work.
jerefprdterra
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“You can be smug now, - i am not having a meltdown why would i its XF, im just saying votes dont make winners. go and speak to the other male winners who won and where are they now???

I was voting for her I wanted her in the final, I would VOTE for my favourite but winning wasnt ever going to happen for Fleur.”

This is very true.
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by mimik1uk:
“votes do make winners tbh , that's the rules of the show

maybe they didn't have success after the show but the previous male winners you refer to still won the show”

Yep and I bet they wish they never did, its quite obvious Simon is going to put Ben to one side for Fleur.
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by IsThisHappiness:
“But why say you never wanted her to win when you've posted thousands of time in the last few weeks saying you did?

Why lie to create a point? It doesn't work.”

yeah wanted her to win, before it was overly obvious she wasnt going to so top 2 was what I wanted, it happened.
mimik1uk
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Yep and I bet they wish they never did, its quite obvious Simon is going to put Ben to one side for Fleur.”

why would they wish they never did ?

if they hadn't won its not like they would have had more promotion or more support than they got for winning ...
IsThisHappiness
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“yeah wanted her to win, before it was overly obvious she wasnt going to so top 2 was what I wanted, it happened.”

So, you did want her to win?

And you saying you didn't previously in this thread, was made up to generate a point trying to justify why she didn't win?

Got it now, thanks.
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by IsThisHappiness:
“So, you did want her to win?

And you saying you didn't previously in this thread, was made up to generate a point trying to justify why she didn't win?

Got it now, thanks.”

Whats with the attitude problem

I said when it was obvious she wasnt going to win, I said Ben would win go and look through all my posts if you like.
mimik1uk
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“yeah wanted her to win, before it was overly obvious she wasnt going to so top 2 was what I wanted, it happened.”

another excuse

if she wins you come on and gloat that you always knew she would win

if she doesn't win you come on and say you really didn't want her to win

just so you can put a positive spin on it either way ...
IsThisHappiness
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Whats with the attitude problem

I said when it was obvious she wasnt going to win, I said Ben would win go and look through all my posts if you like.”

What attitude? Me realising your lie?

Fleurs % didn't dramatically fall In the final, so it's safe to assume she didn't win, not because people thought it was obvious as wouldn't, but because she just didn't have the support.
Nicola123
16-12-2014
ben won which i think is the best result as he is the best singer. fluer maybe able to dance but she doesnt have the greatest voice yes she can sing but ben is a much better singer. its not a dancing competition also ben was top with the public vote for the past 7 weeks he deserves it so much fluer was never top with public and therefore didnt deserve to win. i think lauren should of been in the final instead of andrea because it should of been taken to deadlock and lauren had the higher number of votes. i dont think it would of changed the winner though but maybe it would of been between ben and lauren instead of ben and fleur
RabidWolverine1
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“You can be smug now, - i am not having a meltdown why would i its XF, im just saying votes dont make winners. go and speak to the other male winners who won and where are they now???

I was voting for her I wanted her in the final, I would VOTE for my favourite but winning wasnt ever going to happen for Fleur.”

Matt Cardle: 3 Albums Charting at 2, 8 & 11 Respectively...Most Recent of which was in 2013. 3 Singles Also in the top 20.

Joe McElderry: 4 Albums Charting at 3, 2, 8 & 15 Respectively...Most Recent of which was in 2012. 2 Singles in the top 10

James Arthur: Number 2 Album and 3 Singles in the Top 20


Sure Leon & Steve struggled to get out of the starting gate but you DONT NEED countless Number 1 Singles/Albums to NOT be considered a Flop.

Conescutive Singles & Albums in the Top 20 Is Successful. Its not setting the world on fire...But far from a "Flop"
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
No because win or lose everyone knew Fleur was clearly going to get signed so whats the big deal??
mmpfb
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Yep and I bet they wish they never did, its quite obvious Simon is going to put Ben to one side for Fleur.”

That may be true. We've witnessed it enough in the past. But if so then it's another nail in the XF coffin as more and more people lose faith in the point of voting.

However, If you're so sure of this, why are you (and other less reasonable Fleur Fans) bothering to fight her battles for her on here? And why did you bother voting?

[I feel I need to put a disclaimer at the bottom of all my posts currently stating that I rate neither Ben or Fleur, particularly.]
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
James arthur was the best male winner we've had. IMO
mmpfb
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“James arthur was the best male winner we've had. IMO”

Way to bring the tone down
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by mmpfb:
“That may be true. We've witnessed it enough in the past. But if so then it's another nail in the XF coffin as more and more people lose faith in the point of voting.

However, If you're so sure of this, why are you (and other less reasonable Fleur Fans) bothering to fight her battles for her on here? And why did you bother voting?

[I feel I need to put a disclaimer at the bottom of all my posts currently stating that I rate neither Ben or Fleur, particularly.]”

Unreasonable me?? Ive said I hope Ben succeeds as well as Fleur, also Fighting battles Im not, I just saying its been 11 years so we all know the winners curse so people will be skeptical, whoever won.
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Daily Mail even wrote a page about winning isnt great.
mimik1uk
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Daily Mail even wrote a page about winning isnt great.”

oh if the daily mail wrote about it that's me convinced ...
RabidWolverine1
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Daily Mail even wrote a page about winning isnt great.”

Ahhh The Daily Mail...The only paper to match the credibility of a Radio 1 DJ from the 70's in court.

Id rather read the Star
IsThisHappiness
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Unreasonable me?? Ive said I hope Ben succeeds as well as Fleur, also Fighting battles Im not, I just saying its been 11 years so we all know the winners curse so people will be skeptical, whoever won.”

Out of the 11 winners - most have been successful. See post above. Joe, Matt, Leona, Alexandra, Sam Bailey, James Arthur and Little Mix have all had an OKAY amount of success. So 7 out of 11 isn't bad.

This curse is decided due to number 1s more than anything. Joe and Matt have had 3 top 10 albums for God sake.
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Im just saying.

Success remains to be seen - from all of them.
IsThisHappiness
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Daily Mail even wrote a page about winning isnt great.”

HOLD UP. THE DAILY MAIL!? I MUST HAVE A LOOK!
Eva_Coco_May
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by IsThisHappiness:
“Out of the 11 winners - most have been successful. See post above. Joe, Matt, Leona, Alexandra, Sam Bailey, James Arthur and Little Mix have all had an OKAY amount of success. So 7 out of 11 isn't bad.

This curse is decided due to number 1s more than anything. Joe and Matt have had 3 top 10 albums for God sake.”

Yes and Simon says okay success isnt good enough - Im sure theyre happy with what they have achieved but Simon is all about the money.
IsThisHappiness
16-12-2014
Originally Posted by Eva_Coco_May:
“Yes and Simon says okay success isnt good enough - Im sure theyre happy with what they have achieved but Simon is all about the money.”

But Simon wasn't the boss when Joe or Matt got their 3rd top 10. Their success is great.
paralax
16-12-2014
Jeez, it's being so cheerful that keeps some people going! That and salivating at the thought of someone failing.

I thought this is the season of good will.
<<
<
3 of 7
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map