Originally Posted by memmh:
“Strictly is supposed to be about people who don't have ballroom/latin dance experience learning those new techniques. That doesn't mean they can't have experience and skill in other dance styles. Personally, I'd love to see more contestants who have previous dance experience in other genres competing on Strictly, as long as they're upfront about their experience, which Natalie was right from the start.
(Denise's 'I just sat on a chair' really annoyed me. She should have just said, 'Yes, I had to dance a bit in Chicago but it wasn't ballroom or latin.' She'd still have received a ton of flak but she'd have been better liked for being honest. It was the way she came across as trying to deceive us that got to a lot of people who might otherwise have defended her. Mind you, I don't think that being partnered with James helped her either.)
I didn't have a problem with Natalie, I had a problem with Artem, who I felt was phoning in his choreography that year, since at lot of it was just a rehash of the choreography he did for Kara, especially the American Smooth - which Len penalised Kara for but loved with Natalie, even though it was pretty much the same dance. Go figure.”
I agree that Denise shot herself in the foot with her silly comment - as you say she should have just been upfront and said her dance experience was non ballroom or latin - I guess even though it was her fault. I think I remember feeling a bit sorry for her, but she and her management should have realised that ,nowadays , everything including old interviews can be checked on the net - I'm not sure why she tried to play experience down - perhaps she was badly advised? I didn't watch the first few series of strictly but someone on here said that Jill Halfpenny tried to play down her prior experience when she did strictly and she actually did have some Latin experience as she'd competed in competitions in her youth - I guess with it being the earlier series she was lucky enough to get away with it - or perhaps it was because she was far more likeable?
Re Artem and Natalie - I know there was quite a bit of criticism of him on this forum for wasting the opportunity he had with Natalie - I think he probably did freestyle too much out of hold in the ballroom, but I think he did come up with different stuff for the Latin - unfortunately we didn't get to see the jive but from tour footage it looked great.....but I'm not sure if it was Artem's lack of imagination or because of problems with Natalie's old injury that some of her ballroom suffered ....even though it was a similar AS to what he did with Kara, I think Natlie did put her own spin on it and she pulled out that breath taking version of it in the finals....I guess what I'm trying to say is, that if I think a pro is letting a contestant down with choreography I won't hold it against the celeb - at the end of the day, they can only dance what they're given and I think Natalie did her best with what she was given especially in the trying circumstances of the media onslaught against her.
Originally Posted by
Hound of Love:
“Precisely why I hope that Mike Tindall will not sign on the dotted line.
The producers have apparently been trying to get Donna Air to sign up, too (she is currently the other half of Duchess Kate's brother).
No to them, but a big yes, to Tomasz Schafernacker!
”
I said earlier in the thread that if Mike Tindall signs up, I think they'll try and manufacture a 'journey' storyline for him so that he wins

I really hope the royal advisers persuade him not to take part.
I remember the producers wanted Donna Air because of the tenuous royal connection a few series ago but she didn't sign up for whatever reason and they got Abbey Clancey instead.I haven't heard any recent rumours about Donna. Apparently they want Robbie Williams' wife this series.
Tomasz sounds good - far more preferable to Mike anyway