I would have chosen Frankie's 'WICKED' dance, Simon and Kristina's Jive, Mark's Superman routine - and Caroline's one where she tripped, so she could do it again cleanly.

If it's true that a lot of people only watch the Final - or a lot of the X Factor viewers start watching once that show is over, I believe these dances would have shown everyone off at their best. Not sure if it would have changed the results though, seeing as Caroline was such a clear favourite this week.

Anyone else agree it could have changed anything?

P.S. This is not 'sour grapes' as I keep reading, am just interested........

Simon: Waltz or Jive (fab dances for diff reasons)
Frankie: Tango (the obvious choice for their fave dance actually, quite peculiar they didn't choose it)
Caroline: AS or QS (both lovely but could've been improved and would've shown she can do ballroom too)
Can't say there are any of Mark's dances I would have liked to see again

Simon's jive or Viennese Waltz

Frankie : Tango
Caroline: American Smooth
Mark : Jive
Simon : Waltz

Scott Mill's crab dance and also Judy's dance where she played tennis, just to see if she can do any better.