• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Results:Would you stop watching if the Doctor became female?
No
72 (53.73%)
Yes
62 (46.27%)
Voters: 134. You can't vote on this poll right now - are you signed in?
Would you stop watching if the Doctor became female?
<<
<
1 of 4
>>
>
Free Radical
22-12-2014
It's one thing for the Master to have a sex change, but it's another thing for the Doctor to cross that line.

This thread is not about discussing whether or not it should happen. That has been discussed to death on DS. I want to focus on whether people who hate the idea would stop watching if it did happen.

I'm not going to vote in the poll, but if I did, I would choose Yes. The change would be too much for me.

The Doctor is not human, but he is essentially male. Gender is not like skin colour. Gender is fundamental to personal identity, while skin colour is just a surface trait.

Would you still watch DW if the Doctor became female?
PaperSkin
22-12-2014
I would continue to watch. I think if the right actress comes along who is the best choice for playing the Doctor at that time then they should go for it. It would be an interesting change and could open up new things to explore.
fastest finger
22-12-2014
So, the thread is called "would you stop watching...?" but the poll asks "will you still watch...?"

Cue some confused people and no possible hope of getting an accurate measure of opinion.
LightMeUp
22-12-2014
Originally Posted by fastest finger:
“So, the thread is called "would you stop watching...?" but the poll asks "will you still watch...?"

Cue some confused people and no possible hope of getting an accurate measure of opinion.”

Yeah I voted No in answer to the question in the title. Should have read the question really but I doubt everyone will do that, so the poll isn't going to work.
Crocodile Tears
22-12-2014
This poll needs a 'Perhaps' option.

The most likely scenario is I'd watch the 1st episode just to confirm that they did indeed make the doctor female for misguided socio-political reasons ( NOT because the best actor for the role happened to be female) and then switch off for good.
Crocodile Tears
22-12-2014
Originally Posted by fastest finger:
“So, the thread is called "would you stop watching...?" but the poll asks "will you still watch...?"

Cue some confused people and no possible hope of getting an accurate measure of opinion.”

Whoops!
Yep, I'm one of those confused people. I answered the TITLE question... Couldn't even see a poll question my iPhone.

@FreeRadical
I'd delete and start again. You won't get be able to gage opinion from this poll because you won't know which question ppl are answering!
ProfMarius
22-12-2014
I answered the poll question, too
(i.e. yes, I'd still watch the show)
garbage456
22-12-2014
Are you Steven Moffat?
garbage456
22-12-2014
Arghhh conflicting questions.

your poll question is the opposite of the thread question. So this poll is now void.
Young Turks
22-12-2014
I would actually start watching if the Doctor became female
Paul_Moreton
22-12-2014
Yes it would be pandering to pressure group with Moffat this is lightly to happen
CD93
22-12-2014
I voted No by mistake - due to differing question

I would of course continue watching to see how it plays out and make my decision then.

I wasn't expecting to enjoy a female Master as much as I did.
Thrombin
22-12-2014
I voted No meaning I wouldn't stop watching. Didn't notice the poll question was different!

I like shows with a female lead. Personally I hope they don't do that as, to me, it wouldn't be the Doctor any more if that happened but the concept of the show with a female lead would still be enjoyable in its own right, I reckon.
johnnysaucepn
22-12-2014
If you're going to say this:
Originally Posted by Free Radical:
“This thread is not about discussing whether or not it should happen. That has been discussed to death on DS.”

then you should probably not say this:
Quote:
“The Doctor is not human, but he is essentially male. Gender is not like skin colour. Gender is fundamental to personal identity, while skin colour is just a surface trait.”

If you've read the discussions, then you know that your statement is controversial, and can only invite rebuttals.
nate1970
22-12-2014
Ugh, only read the thread title, so voted incorrectly.
SJ_Mental
22-12-2014
No, I would stop watching if I no longer enjoyed it though male or female doctor.
grazemytvaddict
22-12-2014
Originally Posted by fastest finger:
“So, the thread is called "would you stop watching...?" but the poll asks "will you still watch...?"

Cue some confused people and no possible hope of getting an accurate measure of opinion.”

Me!!
ukgnome
22-12-2014
I would continue watching, but in all honesty I would have to vent my spleen!
GDK
22-12-2014
Originally Posted by fastest finger:
“So, the thread is called "would you stop watching...?" but the poll asks "will you still watch...?"

Cue some confused people and no possible hope of getting an accurate measure of opinion.”

Yes. I fell into that trap, and there's no way to recant!
Granny McSmith
22-12-2014
I, too, voted incorrectly because I assumed the thread title was also the poll question.

Judging by the number of posters this has happened to, perhaps all "no" votes should count as "yes", and vice versa!
GDK
22-12-2014
I've just requested the mods correct and reset this poll.
Free Radical
22-12-2014
Originally Posted by GDK:
“I've just requested the mods correct and reset this poll.”

Thanks. Sorry for the confusion
THE ROTCOD
22-12-2014
having clara version 200 call herself the doctor was sickening enough
andy1231
22-12-2014
Damn I was fooled by the question as well and voted wrongly. It would be the end of Dr Who for me if they changed the sex of the character. How to finally end a programmes that has lasted over 5o years.
THE ROTCOD
22-12-2014
what's the point off the poll.women aren't agrived that the doctor hasent and never will be a woman .otherwise they wouldn't watch
<<
<
1 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map