Hey look as always I'm not going to put a gun to your head and tell you that you must like Honeymoon Rocketpop.
I've honestly really loved Honeymoon and I feel there are songs on the album that could work very well as singles if they are promoted. Whether that will happen or not is another question. Lana's real problem is that its always an uphill battle to get radio to play her music and unless she makes some spectacular video or they get used on films/TV/adverts it can be difficult to attract mainstream interest.
Rick Nowels has worked with a mixture of cool people and cheesy people throughout his career. I personally don't think his talent is in doubt, he's generally performed to whatever standard is required of him.
As far as his work with Lana goes we're looking at everything from Summertime Sadness, Young and Beautiful, Body Electric, Cola to the songs on this album etc, etc. I'd say he's got a pretty good track record at collaborating on some of her best loved songs. I don't have an issue with the work they've made together.
When it was announced it was just her and Rick on this album I did initially worry they'd taken too much work on. However I'm honestly really pleased with the results and its something of a personal victory for her. I'm not against her working with multiple producers, she already seems to have indicated the next album will go down that route again, but I don't think it sounds worse for it being just her and Rick.
Just going back to something you said on earlier on the thread it does surprise me that Lana never worked with Justin Parker (Video Games, Born to Die, Ride etc) again, but I don't think the music she has done since has necessarily suffered without him. Maybe both Lana and Justin felt they'd taken that partnership as far as it could go and decided it was time to move on.
Also I would say don't underestimate the role Lana plays in writing the songs too. True she doesn't get involved in the instrumentation of songs and relies on the songwriters/producers she works with for that but she does come up with the melody (as well as the lyrics) of the songs herself.
Check this interview out with long time collaborator Dan Heath talking about the Big Eyes sountrack for evidence of that:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jMDcW2h3qVE
Quote:
“"Lana saw the film first, she came up with the idea... for the hook... she sang me the idea....I started building the music underneath..."
"The collaborative process works in two ways. Sometimes she sings me a melody lyric idea which I'll build up the music around which was the case for Big Eyes. Sometimes I'll write out a piano or string piece or like a fully flushed out track that she'll sing the melody and lyrics to... she always likes to do her own melody and lyrics...if its not me writing a flushed out track for her to sing on top of its her singing me a melody for me to build up a piece of music around her voice. So that's the two ways we collaborate and it seems to work very well both ways."”
Shock horror (was it ever in doubt?) Lana really does come up with the ideas for her own material.