Originally Posted by Fudd:
“The show was too dated in it's original format”
Less dated than Birds of a Feather and Thunderbirds but they've brought those back (and, in the case of at least the former, without much freshening up).
On the other hand, I'm just watching it now and I am going to go out and a limb and say I don't really understand the reaction.
Here's a list of the show's concepts: boring theme tune, unexciting graphics, naff set, repetitive one-toned audience reactions which were completely over-the-top about every act, presenter making awful jokes, dull VT's about boring family lives, cliched and terrible dance routines, tacky props treated seriously, every contestant so far being from Slough, the moment where he "just happened to have a guitar here" and be amazing despite having never played before.. and I've only watched 20 minutes. It's nothing more than a spot-on parody of everythibg most of the population finds naff about these shows.
I can absolutely understand why it would go down badly with typical ITV viewers who are used to taking the X Factor as seriously as a general election, or those who recall the original format as though it were a much-loved late relative, but then again ITV already provide for those audiences enough so perhaps it's for the best that they finally find something which might find the opposite audience. It's not perfectly executed, admittedly, but it
is a
damn sight more interesting than the 406th repeat of Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone or You've Been Framed, and certainly better than 'Splash' or 'Your Face Sounds Familair' which weren't receieved anything like an unanimously-negatively as this has been. Well done ITV for having the guts to not only comission something new at last but something decent and maybe even innovative at that.