Originally Posted by cylon6:
“Wasn't Vanessa also replacing Kilroy who was axed by BBC1. Tel's recollection of this time is iffy. Liddiment was at ITV around that time. Anne & Nick was a This Morning knock off. BBC1 adopting an approach of not fighting like with like helped them in daytime. Looking at BBC1 the only show still there from 1986 is The One O'Clock News.”
Vanessa didn't replace Kilroy, because Kilroy was somewhat amazingly there until 2004 before he had to, cough, go away. The omnipresence of Kilroy on BBC daytime was amazing, no matter how many revamps there were of BBC daytime it stayed there, eventually lasting over seventeen years. Even though it seemed like a sitting duck in the schedules and when it finished the ratings for the 9am hour on BBC1 shot up.
Wogan gets the chornology confused in his book because Wogan's Island was a few years before Wogan's Web, when David Liddiment was indeed at the BBC, not as Controller of BBC1 but as Head of Entertainment. He was there around the same time as Nick Elliott was Head of Drama, both of whom had been headhunted by the Beeb from ITV to create some more populist programming, but neither really enjoyed it at the Beeb and both returned to ITV within a year or so.
Originally Posted by JordyD:
“Christine Bleakley, Adrian Chiles, Susanna Reid, Julia Bradbury, Mel & Sue, the woman who presented Escape to the Country, it's just the latest in a long line of BBC poach failures.”
The woman who presented Escape to the Country? Don't remember that one on the front page of the tabloids. Getting a bit fed up of the idea any presenter doing anything for more than one channel is them being "poached". Julia Bradbury is a freelance presenter who left Countryfile, not the BBC, as the reports at the time make abundantly clear -
http://www.theguardian.com/media/201...ountryfile-itv
It even says in the piece that she had already done Take On The Twisters for ITV while on Countryfile and would possibly do other shows on the Beeb. She is not on a golden handcuffs deal with ITV, she is a freelance presenter who works for anyone. If anyone can find anything to contradict that, I would absolutely love to see it.
Presenters presenting on more than one channel has happened since ITV began in the fifties. In the seventies Brucie did regular specials for ITV while also doing the Generation Game on the Beeb. More recently Charlie Brooker did Ten O'Clock Live and Black Mirror on C4 while still doing all his BBC shows. It's easier than ever for presenters to work across the various channels, nobody cares and because of independent productions they can work with all the same people regardless of the channel.
Mel and Sue is a Princess production, as was Light Lunch, so it's not beyond the realms of possibility that Mel and Sue or Princess came up with the idea of bringing back a Mel and Sue chat show and approached the various broadcasters, and it was ITV who decided they wanted to do it. It doesn't interfere with any of their BBC work which clearly they're still doing. Yeah, they're a bit of a hotter property now than they were before Bake-Off so ITV were a bit more interested but to suggest they were poached is rubbish.
Originally Posted by JordyD:
“I thought we'd been here before, didn't Mel co present the 5 o'clock show with Richard Hammond? That bombed aswell didn't it?”
Yes, she did. ITV must have "poached" Richard Hammond as well, I suppose, as you can see by the fact he's not on Top Gear anymo... oh, hang on.
The Five O'Clock Show was an attempt to fill the other six months of the year when ITV had Paul O'Grady. I know they originally approached Chris Evans to do that but he turned it down. It wasn't much of a hit, no, because it wasn't much of a format.
Originally Posted by RobbieSykes123:
“I suppose Count Arthur was stable but it's still a disappointing number. The flying lesson scene last night was hilarious. It so deserves a wider audience and it's a shame it's at 10.35pm. Would love to see how it performed on a winter Saturday teatime in say the slot Now You See It currently has”
It is impressive to see it pretty much level week on week because generally with sitcoms the only way is down. Certainly on BBC2 it was getting less than half that at some point. I assume the idea is to hope everyone forgets it was on BBC2 and watch it catch on via word of mouth as they did with Mrs Brown. The fact it's hung on to much of its audience is a good sign, and it does seem to have been a stronger series so far. So give it time. Presumably these days the Beeb are so scared of sitcoms getting roundly slagged off the second they appear they want to give them all the softest of soft launches.