Originally Posted by PJMillar:
“Really really good post. I was watching one of the early re-runs of Who Wants to be a Millionaire? on Challenge, and I couldn't quite put my feelings into words. But you just have.
I mean, if ITV wanted, they could give it another kick-start by giving it a week of 9pm slots, perhaps in the Winter, to really give it an audience back. Sod the ridiculous revamp. The show was brilliant as it was, and it was the endless Christmas/celebrity charity specials that killed it.
Similarly, it's just a shame that there's hardly a successful gameshow where ordinary people are the focus. Mr & Mrs and Family Fortunes, once shows that epitomised the fortunes of the ordinary (often working class) person, now they're glossy and feed celebrity egos.”
Would love to see Family Fortunes return to using regular folk - and surely in these credit crunch times it'll be cheaper for the TV companies than booking a so called celeb.
Another example is Alan Carr's Celebrity Ding Dong. The first series was quite interesting having celebrities with civilians and provided loads of comedy material, mainly at the expense of the civilians - but then for the second they ditched the civilians and it just became another celebrity panel show.
Also Total Wipeout. Putting how the BBC have ****ed up a great format to one side, the shows strength is all about the general public having their one shot on the course. So what do the BBC do - announce two new series, with 4 celebrity specials over the next year.
And considering the show needs 20 contestants a week, that's 80 celebs required to fly to Argentina and compete - an experience I'm sure 80 licence fee payers would appreciate much more. (Hopefully though they've struggled to sign up the celebs so it'll be just the one Celebrity "special".)
I think a reason Christmas TV is so bad now is because the celebrity "special" is no longer special. Even as little as 10 years ago Christmas was really the only time you saw celebs on such shows - now it's every bloody week.