Hi guys,

I'm at my parents' house this week so might not be able to post comments during the show

But I couldn't resist popping on to start this thread.

Enjoy the show,
Ellie

As luck would have it - I'm here for now... bring 'em on.
Last edited by ellie4265 : 01-04-2005 at 20:35

Good God, what's with the hat Bo!?!?!?

#I didn't even recognise him!

[list][*]Bo Bice - I think he missed his cue at the beginning because his timing on the first line was off. Great singing and emotive performance but I hated the song … oh, and the hat![*]Jessica Sierra - I Love her voice but I didn’t know the song and it sounded quite a messy arrangement.[/list]

Jesus Anwar, this is painful!

[list][*]Anwar Robinson - His tuning was dodgy again for the first half and his voice sounds weak and thin when he’s singing slow - he pulled it back in the second half when he livened up though.[/list]

Quick review while the ads are on:

Bo - is rapidly becoming my favourite - odd as I'm not a rock lover His voice was good tonight but the choice of song dire

Jessica - bad song choice, performance did nothing for me

Anwar - oh dear, that was awful, he will need to stop trying so hard if he's going to stay in, shame as he was my favourite

Paula is DRUNK or on DRUGS!!!

[list][*]Nadia Turner - Didn’t know this song either, which always spoils a performance for me. The song was a bit drab but she gave a great performance and sounded good. Good to see her pull back from last week! [/list]

Too much theatrics from Constantine!

[list][*]Constantine Maroulis - Another song I didn’t know! For the first time, I actually noticed that he has a nice tone to his voice but he went way over the top on the facial theatrics though. A good performance.[*]Nikko Smith - Back on form tonight. Still a few dodgy notes (including that last, long note! ) but overall a good performance.[/list]

I don't like nikko.

Ooooh, I know this song!

Hmmm, I'm not too impressed so far - is it just that I don't know the songs?

[list][*]Anthony Fedorov - A song I know at last but I really didn’t like Anthony’s version - He messed with the arrangement too much and was way too shouty at the end.[/list]

ROTFLMAO @ Simon's feedback for Anthony:

S: “That was excruciating in parts”
P: “Which parts?”
S: “Beginning, middle and end!”

O ... M ... G!!!! Scott!!!! This is dire!!!!!!!!!

That was really funny.

[list][*]Carrie Underwood - Back to another song I don’t know. She’s another one who has trouble hitting the notes when singing softly and she sounded shouty when she belted them out. An OK performance.[*]Scott Savol - Absolutely dire - off-key throughout virtually the whole song![/list]

What is 'pitchy'?

edit: what does it mean?

Off-key/not in tune.

can't they just say ...'you were off-key'?

Lol, perhaps it's an American thing.

Nadia - better than last week, but still not brilliant

Nikko - okay

Constantine - my favourite performance from him

Anthony - too musical theatre for me

Carrie - I find her very boring, she does the same thing every week :yawn: No doubt she will win this show though

Scott - I actually enjoyed his performance, I did what Paula did and closed my eyes, it does help