Originally Posted by mushymanrob:
“bib... erm... you just did!”
wrong again. have a read back. you are reading one thing and yet again interpreting something in your brain that's not been said
Quote:
“
all those programmes you highlight arent on the 4 main terestrial channels that we had by the early 80's. by default - more channels,”
you prove my point
Quote:
“
i like some of the programmes you list....
of course there are some great tv progs atm, but id suggest not as many, especially on the 4 main terrestrial (ok ok 5 if you want to include the joke station).”
again this is just a pointless statement. i've not mentioned any quantity, so how could you suggest not as many?
and most people in the uk have had far more than 4 or 5 channels for the last 10+ years with freeview, and going back over 20 years for those who subscribed to sky or cable/virgin
there's a tv section of the forum, have a look in there and see how popular some shows are. tv shows are as subjective as anything else, what you might not like others will like. of course there's piles of cheaply made reality tv crap, but there are a load of quality scripted dramas and comedies, to which few if any will like all of them, just like music, but some shows will appeal to some and other shows will appeal to others, but there are many great popular shows with widespread appeal such as some of those i mentioned, and that's just a tiny sample of shows
Quote:
“
some great comedies?... where?...”
have a look in the tv forums for some suggestions. it will depend on your sense of humour, be it curb your enthusiasm, californication, workaholics, modern family, parks and recreation, the last man on earth, man seeking woman, the goldbergs, etc
Quote:
“
wheres the comedy of the caliber that got people still re-enacting them days/months/years after they were first broadcast?”
on tv. just because you might not see folk re-enact comedy doesn't mean the comedy isn't of the same or higher caliber. you seem to again be referring to a past time when there were less channels, less things to watch so more people say the same thing, whereas today there is a much wider choice and wider variety of all sorts of things from music to tv, with different things for different tastes, so people will often watch different things
perhaps in this day and age people know that re-enacting comedy is sad, lame, boring and bloody annoying. some idiot at work repeating a phrase they heard on tv is usually the opposite of funny, and with forums and social media people are more aware of annoying things and less likely to do them as they know they are mocked behind their backs
Quote:
“
wheres the people talking about modern comedy with the affection they did when remembering the great sketches?”
all over the place, just like the past, but of course time needs to pass for current things to become nostalgic. again, look at the tv forums to see what people are saying about todays shows. there's probably more talk about todays shows than ever before as there are more options to do so, and the ability to discuss shows with people from across the world, whereas in person in the past if you liked a show but didn't know others who did, your conversation would be limited
Quote:
“
wheres todays "dont tell him pike"?
or the hundreds of catchphrases to make us still laugh? whos talking about them the same way we all did for monty python? fawlty towers? young ones? blackadder? father ted? fast show?”
look in the tv forums. modern comedy usually doesn't rely on a catch phrase that dates and annoys quickly. who wants to watch whats basically a repeat of the same sketch changed slightly each week with the same catchphrase? dave or uk gold is the channel for you if that's what you like. if you like old stuff, there's plenty of variety over decades, and plenty avenues from tv channels to netflix and youtube and dvd and vhs to view it. pretty similar to music, if you don't like new music there are plenty avenues to listen to old music instead
Quote:
“
nah..... youll not convince me theres great comedies around now to the caliber of those mentioned.”
you say that as if i would care
Quote:
“
but i do think theres a comparison between comedy and (pop) music.... both became popular in the 50's/60's, both evolved through the 70's - 90's , and both appear to have run out of ideas (in respect to discovering new styles) over the last 10 odd years. maybe both art forms have run a parallel existence and have discovered all the new ways in which they can be created.”
music and comedy have been popular long before the 50s and 60s and are more popular today than ever, and certainly haven't ran out of ideas. there's an absolutely huge potential for even greater variety in music than there is today, and i see the roots of that change today, just like i saw the roots of todays variety back in the early 80s and onwards. there's more new styles around today than ever before