if you don't mind i'll use your rankings and do an overall total with everyone giving points from 8 (for your fave obviously) to 0, i'll do that Wednesday night

i might do this every week

1 Carrie

although she has a wonderful voice my hearts still not with her, she lacks charisma. she's no Diana thats for sure

2 Vonzell

amazing on IHN, she could take Carrie as my #1 if shes good this week

3 Anthony

the judges don't seem to like him much but he does some great glory notes and is cute at times

4 Nikko

VERY pitchy, but i think he's cool and he tends to finish his songs very well

5 Anwar

he's been pretty rubbish since Wonderful World and i've gone off him a lot. but i can't say there are many i like this year

6 Nadia

You Don't Have To Say You Love Me was a class act but since then she hasn't been anywhere near as good

7 Scott

his voice is good, too much verbrato though. still needs to do more on stage

8 Bo

he was terrible this week! i would not love to see a rocker win

9 Constantine

i actually liked him this week. i've gone from hating him to just feeling he's not my thing. he can probably still jump up my rankings with a knockout performance of a song i know and love



on another note

at this stage last year we had...

Diana who i adore
Latoya who gave some top notch performances. no vocals have been at the same level this year
Fantasia who was patchy, i disliked her but i appreciated she was good
Jasmine who was lovely and had a beautiful voice if a little pitchy
George who was fun and was still on form around this time
Jennifer who was amazing!

and Camille, JPL and John who were not good singers but still had that little something that made them worth watching


i don't think this season can even hold a candle to last time. it seems to lack heart

Hi Saturn


I've just got to say that I really couldn't care less about ANY of them.I'm now videoing it and using the ff button to speed up the whole snoozefest.Sorry that I don't care enough about these people to bother putting them in any order.Hope you get more worthy input from others here.

1. Vonzell - I just love this girl and she's improving!
2. Carrie - Flawless voice!
3. Nadia - I like her performances!
4. Nikko - Different to the other lads!
5. Bo - Great voice!
6. Constantine - Improving IMO!
7. Anwar - He has a great voice, but hasn't shown his full potential yet!
8. Scott - He does have a nice voice! It's a pity about everything else!
9. Anthony - He bores me!

I think AI4 has more overall talent in the Final 9 than AI3, but Fantasia, La Toya and Jennifer were the best!

hey there, no probs

i've been feeling the same way lately but i hope it picks up. i really miss the themed nights (with guest judges) and actually hearing songs i actually know would be a bonus. Paula is worse than ever

this series also seems to be more controlled voting wise than ever before

On this week not overall.

9 Carrie

8. Constantine

7.Bo(although I hated the hat

6.Vonzell

5.Nadia

4.Anwar

3.Nikko

2.Anthony

1.Scott

8 - Bo - he's a star already - what a great rock voice!
7 - Anwar - lovely voice, was my favourite but has a knack of choosing wrong songs for his voice, so relegated to 2nd favourire.
6 - Nadia - great performer, but also sometimes chooses wrong songs
5 - Vonzell - most improved - good voice, not outstanding, but good performer
4- Carrie - yes she has a great voice, but find her a bit boring - sorry all you Carrie fans - you can tell I'm not a Country music fan!
3- Nikko - another one who's improved - may go up in my list if he continues to get better
2 - Constantine - OK, but nothing special
1- Anthony - sweet guy but not a great voice
0 - Scott - voice OK, but very dull personality

8 - Constantine
7 - Nadia
6 - Vonzell
5 - Bo
4 - Carrie
3 - Anwar
2 - Nikko
1 - Scott
0 - Antony

very clear bottom 2 so far

8. Bo
7. Anwar
6. Carrie
5. Vonzell


4. Nadia

Just like all these four to go next week:
3. Nikko :sleep:
2. Scott
1. Constantine
0. Anthony

8 Bo
7 Nadia
6 Anwar
5 Vonzell
4 Nikko
3 Constantine
2 Scott
1 Anthony:sleep:
0 Carrie:yawn: :sleep:

8. Vonzell (both vonzell and nadia are stars)!!
7. Nadia
6. Nikko
5. Bo
4. Anthony
3. Constantine
2. Carrie (i think she is over-rated)
1. Scott

and nothing for Anwar?

8. Nadia
7. Bo
6. Vonzell
5. Carrie
4. Nikko
3. Anwar :yawn:
2. Constantine
1. Anthony :sleep:
0. Scott

8. Vonzell
7. Bo
6. Nadia
5. Nikko
4. Constantine
3. Anthony
2. Carrie
1. Anwar
0. Scott

thanks for all the responses

9 Carrie
8 Bo
7.Vonzell
6.Nikko
5.Constantine
4. Nadia
3. Anwar
2. Scott(very wierd person)
1. Anthony

9 Carrie (Clear Winner)
8 Bo
7.Vonzell
6.Nadia
5.Nikko
4. Constantine
3. Scott
2. Anthony
1. Anwar

Sour grapes anyone?

9 Carrie

8 to 1 ? Do I HAVE to?

8 Constantine

7 Bo

6 Nadia

5 Vonzel

4 Scott

3 Anthony

2 Nikko

1 Anwar

8. Bo
7. Nadia
6. Vonzell
5. Scott
4. Anwar (I like him but he has to improve)
3. Anthony :sleep:
2. Constantine
1. Nikko
0. Carrie :yawn:

14 votes in, 2 days to vote

results are still changeable in places

interesting how Carrie seems to be love or hate

8. Constantine 7. Anthony 6. Vonzell 5. Carrie 4. Bo 3. Nadia 2. Nikko 1. Anwar 0. Scott (yuck!)

I wonder how many of the Carrie haters would stake their house and savings that if they all released albums in the US tomorrow, she'd be the worst selling or close to it!

None with any sense.

It may not be your type of music, but she's VERY good at it, and has also produced the best performance easily of the series in a different genre!

i agree but its up to the voters

this poll isn't a be all and end all and i'm sure she'll be there come the final 2

8. Bo ( amazing)

7. Constantine ( he really has a great voice)
6. Anthony ( ok he is more musical theatre than pop but the boy can sing)
5. Anwar... he is getting a bit samey though
4. nadia... best of the girls
3. Vonzell, ( she really needs the right song and she will blow them away)
2. scott ... nice pleasant vocal and he is not the same every performance
1 Nicko
0 .carrie ... ok she may win but country music is like getting a tooth pulled and I don't like the dentist.

9. Nadia - Not the best techinical singer but the most interesting to me.
8. Bo
7. Anwar (based on earlier performances and me hoping he will get back there)
6. Vonzell - only fourth because I had no early loyalty to her
5. Constantine
4. Carrie - Can't see why Americans like her so much.
3. Nikko - boring
2. Anthony - very boring
1. Scott - horrible