Originally Posted by lewismacf:
“Cheryl Has been sacked too”
“Cheryl Has been sacked too”
Nothing has been confirmed about Louis and Cheryl being sacked. It just seems to be media gossip at the moment.
Cowell to Sack Louis Walsh
2 of 2
Nothing has been confirmed about Louis and Cheryl being sacked. It just seems to be media gossip at the moment.
Originally Posted by Soapfan678:
“Nothing has been confirmed about Louis and Cheryl being sacked. It just seems to be media gossip at the moment.”
“Nothing has been confirmed about Louis and Cheryl being sacked. It just seems to be media gossip at the moment.”
Well, I can always hope that it turns out to be true
Originally Posted by Gavin_Martin:
“i know one person who will not miss louis walsh if he goes is Cher Lloyd everyone knows why”
“i know one person who will not miss louis walsh if he goes is Cher Lloyd everyone knows why”
Why? Because Cher came across as a spoilt brat at the time, who was rude and could not accept any form of constructive criticism?
They're getting it all wrong. Louis and Cheryl need to sling their hook, keep Melanie and replace the other two with Sia and someone else
Originally Posted by Soapfan678:
“Why? Because Cher came across as a spoilt brat at the time, who was rude and could not accept any form of constructive criticism?”
“Why? Because Cher came across as a spoilt brat at the time, who was rude and could not accept any form of constructive criticism?”
Because Louis was rude to cher and noone is backing Louis Walsh even from Simon about cher coming across as a spoilt brat
He's on Ant & Dec tonight, they normally have people from the 'ITV Family' in the show, if Louis was gonna be aXed then i doubt they'd have him on there, just my speculation.
Originally Posted by m-river:
“They're getting it all wrong. Louis and Cheryl need to sling their hook, keep Melanie and replace the other two with Sia and someone else”
“They're getting it all wrong. Louis and Cheryl need to sling their hook, keep Melanie and replace the other two with Sia and someone else”
Sia where did that come from she hasnt even been rumoured. She is a great artist with an amazing voice but To be honest I dont think she has the right personality for X Factor.
I would love to see
Simon
Cheryl
Tulisa
Gary Barlow
as judges but I doubt Simon would want to be on the same panel as Gary and vice versa
Originally Posted by stv viewer:
“Sia where did that come from she hasnt even been rumoured. She is a great artist with an amazing voice but To be honest I dont think she has the right personality for X Factor.
I would love to see
Simon
Cheryl
Tulisa
Gary Barlow
as judges but I doubt Simon would want to be on the same panel as Gary and vice versa”
“Sia where did that come from she hasnt even been rumoured. She is a great artist with an amazing voice but To be honest I dont think she has the right personality for X Factor.
I would love to see
Simon
Cheryl
Tulisa
Gary Barlow
as judges but I doubt Simon would want to be on the same panel as Gary and vice versa”
Gary, Tulisa and Cheryl are dull and simon looked weak next to mel last year. that wouldn't balance out the panel 2 borings bints, a broken record and an idiot who thinks he's god
Originally Posted by m-river:
“Gary, Tulisa and Cheryl are dull and simon looked weak next to mel last year. that wouldn't balance out the panel 2 borings bints, a broken record and an idiot who thinks he's god”
“Gary, Tulisa and Cheryl are dull and simon looked weak next to mel last year. that wouldn't balance out the panel 2 borings bints, a broken record and an idiot who thinks he's god”
To be truthful up till last week I wanted Olly Murs to be a judge but I dont think that will happen as it seems he will be the new host which I think he will be good at.
Originally Posted by Gavin_Martin:
“Because Louis was rude to cher and noone is backing Louis Walsh even from Simon about cher coming across as a spoilt brat”
“Because Louis was rude to cher and noone is backing Louis Walsh even from Simon about cher coming across as a spoilt brat”
The viewers could see Cher was a brat and the blatant fixing for her to make the final
Originally Posted by Gavin_Martin:
“i know one person who will not miss louis walsh if he goes is Cher Lloyd everyone knows why”
“i know one person who will not miss louis walsh if he goes is Cher Lloyd everyone knows why”
I don't think many people particularly care why.
In my mind they probably need to drop Cheryl and Louis. Cheryl didn't succeed in doing anything for the show and, by the end of series 7, had lost a lot of popularity anyway. Louis has just passed his sell by date; unless they can turn him back into the judge he was in the early series (where he was actually critical and on point) then he should go.
As for replacements they have to be realistic. I think Nicole should be re-introduced if possible as she worked well enough with Simon on the US series and has a mad side which would ease the loss of Louis. I'd like to see Robbie Williams on the panel but am not holding my breath. If he can't/won't do it then Olly might be a reasonable choice as he at least has a personality. He will go easy on the acts though so Simon and Mel B will need to be used as counterpoints.
Originally Posted by zerothehero:
“The viewers could see Cher was a brat and the blatant fixing for her to make the final”
“The viewers could see Cher was a brat and the blatant fixing for her to make the final”
Originally Posted by Fudd:
“I don't think many people particularly care why.
In my mind they probably need to drop Cheryl and Louis. Cheryl didn't succeed in doing anything for the show and, by the end of series 7, had lost a lot of popularity anyway. Louis has just passed his sell by date; unless they can turn him back into the judge he was in the early series (where he was actually critical and on point) then he should go.
As for replacements they have to be realistic. I think Nicole should be re-introduced if possible as she worked well enough with Simon on the US series and has a mad side which would ease the loss of Louis. I'd like to see Robbie Williams on the panel but am not holding my breath. If he can't/won't do it then Olly might be a reasonable choice as he at least has a personality. He will go easy on the acts though so Simon and Mel B will need to be used as counterpoints.”
“I don't think many people particularly care why.
In my mind they probably need to drop Cheryl and Louis. Cheryl didn't succeed in doing anything for the show and, by the end of series 7, had lost a lot of popularity anyway. Louis has just passed his sell by date; unless they can turn him back into the judge he was in the early series (where he was actually critical and on point) then he should go.
As for replacements they have to be realistic. I think Nicole should be re-introduced if possible as she worked well enough with Simon on the US series and has a mad side which would ease the loss of Louis. I'd like to see Robbie Williams on the panel but am not holding my breath. If he can't/won't do it then Olly might be a reasonable choice as he at least has a personality. He will go easy on the acts though so Simon and Mel B will need to be used as counterpoints.”
Well zerothehero simon cowell did dismiss reports that the semi final in 2010 was fix for cher to be in the final and Fudd Shayne Ward will miss Louis Walsh if he goes, plus Andy Abraham said on Channel 5 on Good Friday that he feels Louis should quit x factor
Originally Posted by Gavin_Martin:
“Well zerothehero simon cowell did dismiss reports that the semi final in 2010 was fix for cher to be in the final and Fudd Shayne Ward will miss Louis Walsh if he goes, plus Andy Abraham said on Channel 5 on Good Friday that he feels Louis should quit x factor”
“Well zerothehero simon cowell did dismiss reports that the semi final in 2010 was fix for cher to be in the final and Fudd Shayne Ward will miss Louis Walsh if he goes, plus Andy Abraham said on Channel 5 on Good Friday that he feels Louis should quit x factor”
So your telling me that springing the sing off in the semi-final on the night when Cher was bottom of the votes is not fixing it to save her?
Originally Posted by zerothehero:
“So your telling me that springing the sing off in the semi-final on the night when Cher was bottom of the votes is not fixing it to save her?”
“So your telling me that springing the sing off in the semi-final on the night when Cher was bottom of the votes is not fixing it to save her?”
for some people yes because looking back now when mary was in the sing off with cher , i kind of knew that cher will be save because cher is younger and mary was too old , might be the reason why mary was voted off
have a look and see for yourself
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4i78uTF2glE
I don't think Louis will go now Dermot has. They won't want to loose two of the shows' only constant faces. It would be high risk to say the least.
Simon needs to sack himself from the show!
Lots of dodgy decisions and iffy goings on with the xfactor, which is understandable due to his vested interest. However, people are catching on to Simon's game hence the declining figures which will decline further next season!
The poor fellow can't see the problem because of his ego!
Lots of dodgy decisions and iffy goings on with the xfactor, which is understandable due to his vested interest. However, people are catching on to Simon's game hence the declining figures which will decline further next season!
The poor fellow can't see the problem because of his ego!
Originally Posted by COTTONHEAT:
“http://www.dailystar.co.uk/showbiz-t...obbie-Williams
i know its from the Daily Star but its got to be done”
“http://www.dailystar.co.uk/showbiz-t...obbie-Williams
i know its from the Daily Star but its got to be done”
I'd be disappointed if Louis left. The show would not be the same without him.
He is a bit clueless sometimes, but I do like that he doesn't take the show too seriously.
Originally Posted by Film and TV Fan:
“I'd be disappointed if Louis left. The show would not be the same without him.
He is a bit clueless sometimes, but I do like that he doesn't take the show too seriously.”
“I'd be disappointed if Louis left. The show would not be the same without him.
He is a bit clueless sometimes, but I do like that he doesn't take the show too seriously.”
You're right, the show wouldn't be the same. But in my opinion that's a good thing.
I would be happy to see the back of Mel and Louis, I didn't mind Cheryl last year and she was a lot more tolerable than 2008-2010, I though Cheryl was a much better judge than Mel.
Although I quite liked Louis years ago when he put decent criticism in and put reasonable effort into mentoring but giving Louis the overs/groups year after year is getting old. Besides he completely stuffed up OTY chances last year.
Although I quite liked Louis years ago when he put decent criticism in and put reasonable effort into mentoring but giving Louis the overs/groups year after year is getting old. Besides he completely stuffed up OTY chances last year.
2 of 2
