I guess the OP didn't get the response he was wanting when he posted it in Gallifrey Base
The Burping Wheelie Bin in "Rose"
2 of 2
It reminded me of the burping frog in Return of the Jedi. Didn't like the joke when I was a 5 year old watching that so why would modern 5 year olds like a burping bin?!
Bad idea and should have never been included. As someone above said, it ruined the tension of the episode.
Bad idea and should have never been included. As someone above said, it ruined the tension of the episode.
I can't believe that people are still complaining about a bloody burping bin. It was 10 years ago. LET. IT. GO.!!!!! 
Originally Posted by Airborae:
“I can't believe that people are still complaining about a bloody burping bin. It was 10 years ago. LET. IT. GO.!!!!!”
“I can't believe that people are still complaining about a bloody burping bin. It was 10 years ago. LET. IT. GO.!!!!!
”
Basically this.
I rewatched Rose the other day and whilst it didn't make me laugh, it raised a smile. And I'm 22.
Originally Posted by doctor blue box:
“I never knew something so small was even a big deal to anyone. I've seen the episode multiple times, but if i'm honest, i'd completely forgotten about the scene until I saw it mentioned, as it's not exactly one of the most important in the episode. I can perhaps understand at the time when it was series 1 episode 1 that maybe people were worried that the whole series would be too silly and not as serious as it should be/used to be, but it seems strange that it would still bother anyone now, especially given all the silly moments we've had since.”
“I never knew something so small was even a big deal to anyone. I've seen the episode multiple times, but if i'm honest, i'd completely forgotten about the scene until I saw it mentioned, as it's not exactly one of the most important in the episode. I can perhaps understand at the time when it was series 1 episode 1 that maybe people were worried that the whole series would be too silly and not as serious as it should be/used to be, but it seems strange that it would still bother anyone now, especially given all the silly moments we've had since.”
Basically this! ^
Originally Posted by Isambard Brunel:
“Who on Earth told you that? You've honestly never heard fans 'whine' about the fight in Nightmare of Eden or the Punch & Judy dinosaurs in Jon Pertwee's time, or Adric or Colin Baker's coat or the Kandyman?!
Or being half human.”
“Who on Earth told you that? You've honestly never heard fans 'whine' about the fight in Nightmare of Eden or the Punch & Judy dinosaurs in Jon Pertwee's time, or Adric or Colin Baker's coat or the Kandyman?!
Or being half human.”
Sssshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!! Practically the entire fan base has been trying to forget that for almost 2 decades now, we don't need any more reminder of that!
2 of 2
