Originally Posted by george.millman:
“They did very clearly write Gemma out of character, for one episode at least. In the episode with the car crash involving Malick, she seemed far more interested in gossiping about it than in actually being concerned about the wellbeing of those involved. In the past she had come across as very caring and compassionate, so that was very odd.
The dynamic between her and Harry didn't work, but I also don't think that should have warranted getting rid of her character entirely. When she first joined, I thought Gemma was a fantastic character - very fiery but able to temper it and get on with her job, highly intelligent (she normally surpassed Arthur in exams), an interesting backstory (the age of her son suggested she'd been a teen mum and having worked as 'Dr Honey' implying she's had to do pretty much everything to support them both), had good morals (wanting to be vegetarian) but a bit naive (thinking free-range chicken was fine). Then they set up the situation with Harry, and all they ever did was have Gemma bring her son in, him disappearing and have Harry find him. Then they suddenly wrote her entirely out of character, before being cut from the show altogether.
I agree with Kitkat, it is very odd what happened there. Perhaps the cast and crew found Ty difficult to work with on set - she could have been argumentative about various things and held them up. From what we've seen she may have had good reason given that her character was written very oddly in at least one episode, but there could have been a few occasions. Who knows? She always seemed lovely in interviews, but you never know. Also I daresay longer-standing cast members can get away with that kind of thing more than newer ones - maybe she was punching above her weight and unintentionally wound people up that way.”
That was exactly the instance I was referring to. In amongst many jaw droppingly bad things in that episode where peope were written out of character (Jonny turning on pregnant Jac after 18 months within 5 minutes seemingly just because a couple of Patient relatives and girl he'd known at college and not seen for 10+ years said she was a bitch from their first impression. Right of course but everybody thinks she's a bitch on first impression, hardly news to him and the baby had been coming before everythin), was Gemma just firing gruesome question after gruesome question about the details of the accident and Malick's injuries to a clearly upset and traumatized Digby. That didn't seem in keeping with Gemma to anybody and certainly not her friend Sniffles (Digby). Meanwhile, MC, who did have a history of being a gossip, lazy and sometimes tactless was behaving like Florence Nightingale. Out of character for both (although it marked the beginning of a more mature MC which perhaps was their intention) and felt as though somebody had just swapped their lines over. Anyway, Glazer stated at the time that she had complained about that scene and been over ruled and only a couple of weeks later it was announced she was going.
It was around the time that Kent took over and maybe her face (character wise) just didn't fit or they didn't take kindly to having an actor arguing about scripts (even if only once) - especially a fairly new to the show actor. Somebody like Quarshie might carry a bit more weight or be harder to shut up. Although, we all know that Marcel objected to Jac having a baby and she was also over ruled so longevity didn't seem to help matters there either.
Also noticeable how many actors did leave within Kent's first few months in charge, some he might not have wanted, some might not have liked the way the show (which drastically changed around that time) or their characters were going and quit.
It's also possible that wasn't going to be an abberation but the start of a permanent change of direction for Gemma (as stated, that episode marked Jonny changing from a fairly good guy to a bit of an arse to virtually everybody, including Patients for more than a year) and they decided that if Ty didn't like it, she could go.
Or the new Producers just didn't see potential in the character full stop - she was created by their predecessors after all, one of the last characters they did create along with Digby and there is always a danger a new Producer will axe characters they don't personally like to make room for new ones they create.