Originally Posted by Alrightmate:
“I understand your opinion, but as you say you would like to see new characters and mythology added. So the mythology exists based on what has been added to it already.
If the characters are there already you may as well use them when it suits.
For me it makes no difference if they bring back The Weeping Angels or bring back a being from pre-2005. To me it's all the same timeline.
With a distinct lack of Timelords around I've love them to bring back Romana if they get the right actress. I saw Mary Tamm as Romana very recently on the Horror channel and she was great. I thought that sort of companion would feel very fresh for The Doctor right now. The Rani from what I've read about her sounds like a very interesting prospect too. They use the Master, but I'd like to see a new nemesis. I think the show is lacking nemesises(plural?)
But I agree with you that they need to introduce new quality characters, which I don't think they created enough of compared to the older era of Who.”
Yeah, I'm with you on that
I guess, as well, we shouldn't forget that there was a great Time War. Even though, ultimately, the Doctor saved his race and the planet, there were still many many years of bloodshed and devastation and war. So to bring back, for example, Leela, Romana, Borusa, Omega, Rassilon, the Rani, any/all these characters we closely associate with Gallifrey might feel a bit unrealistic. Saving Gallifrey was heroic and a nice 'happy ever after', but that shouldn't take away from the amount of chaos and war that still occurred. I think they maybe risk taking away the impact of the Time War if they were to bring characters that we closely associate with Gallifrey back. So, for me anyway, if they brought back Romana, that'd be the only classic series Time Lord I'd want to see. Or the same with Leela. Or whatever. I think it'd be more interesting to see the Doctor head back home, maybe in search of Leela, to then be informed or to find out she was one of the casualties of the War.
Even though the War ended on an upbeat note, so to speak, there should still be consequence and casualties, and I believe Peter Capaldi could pull that conflicted character off brilliantly; the fact that, yes, his former selves saved the day, but that he still lost many friends and family in the years prior to the final day