Originally Posted by kitkat1971:
“Exactly. It isn't fair on the other actors, not getting the correct 'feed' line can really throw them off.
Re stuff staying in. As one writer i talked to about it (not a soap by the way), the problem can be that if the writer isn't on the floor that day, it might not get noticed if it isn't a major difference and by the time the writer sees it to object in editing it is too late to get it refilmed. So they're stuck with it. But the writer can be majorly ++++ed off about it. As he termed it, you spend hours or days slaving over a script, getting the 'tone' and 'beat' just right and then some 'jumped up, unqualified actor that has never studied writing in their life' ((his words) completely changes the meaning of the scene by thinking they know better.
Now that is more the case of an actor deliberately changing it rather than just covering for a forgotten line but the principle remains the same. Writers have studied their craft and are paid because they are good at it. Actors have studied their craft and are paid because they are good at it. They shouldn't presume to think they know better than somebody else in another 'department' and people will get upset if it reguarly happens.
It is a matter of professional pride. Think how a writer would feel if viewers were moaning about an awful line and saying that writer is crap because their name is on the credits but actually an actor has written it?
As i understand it most of Dyer's ad libs are usually the cockney rhyming slang rather than actual dialogue content. It doesn't change the meaning of scenes.”
Oh! This reminds of the time that Alun Armstrong from New Tricks once slagged off the writers and said the actors occasionally wrote their own scripts....one of the writers responded on twitter with the below...OUCH!
"A New Tricks I wrote and directed airs on Monday. I can tell you EXACTLY how much of it the actors wrote: not a comma," said Julian Simpson on Twitter.
"The following week, Sarah Pinborough's episode is on. I directed that too. Cast contribution to script? Big fat zero."
"I was going to be writing today, instead I'm just going to hand the actors a pad and pen. I wish I'd learned this 15 years ago," he added, before noting: "Worth saying that I get on phenomenally well with the New Tricks cast.
"Just don't appreciate actors speaking out of turn and they know that."