Just a poll to see who DS's favourite BGT judge is, you can provide reasons if you wish.

amanda holden

Simon! But I like them all on BGT and think the panel works really well how it is at the moment

Yes, this.

Between Simon and David for me, but I chose David. Yes, he is a little questionable sometimes, but he is the most fun.

Amanda's okay - though this is kind of the only way she's famous anymore.
Alesha I don't like. She adds nothing to the show.
Simon I like, though I don't like the way he claims to "not like" certain acts (joke acts) though ends up putting them into the semi finals so he can A) make a mockery out of them and B) get better ratings.

David Walliams by far. Hugely entertaining judge who has helped to freshen up the show. BGT would no longer be the same without him. Here's hoping he does it next year also.

Alesha Dixon for me

For once DS seem to agree with the general public.

i like david, dislike the rest.

David Walliams is the funniest, but Simon Cowell is the realist on the panel, so I vote Simon. The other 3 judges put too many joke acts through.

Amanda Holden

I would put Simon and Alesha as the most likeable.

I don't find anything funny about David, but I appreciate what is seen as funny and humourous is subjective. Amanda is just about tolerable.

I like all of them, but David Walliams is my favorite.

David - and I'd say this annoys Simon

David and Amanda probably, since they put the most variety through. But Simon is obviously amazing too.

I love Alesha, but not nearly as much as I used to - she doesn't look she has as much fun as she did in 2012 & 2013.

Hopefully this panel will stick around for 2016 so they can have had 5 years

David by a million miles.

Nooooooooooooo i ment say alesha but said Amanda

So pleased DW is leading the poll because I only ever see him being slated around here.

I like him lots.

Amanda Holden.

She has a lovely smile.

David. Think the panel is great together and I wouldn't change it.