The speculation of this story gives me really bad memories of this
From wikipedia
Quote:
“The Salem Stalker and Melaswen Island[edit]
Days of Our Lives had been losing viewers in early 2000. The show managed to lure back James E. Reilly, who had left the show in 1997 to create his own soap opera, Passions.[28][29][30] NBC said at the time that the show, "Needed a fix, and we had the fix right here."[31] James E. Reilly began crafting a big story for the 2003–2004 season. Viewers were shocked to see long-term veteran Abe Carver (James Reynolds) shot at his front doorstep by a strange cloaked figure.[32] Next, viewers saw Jack Deveraux (Matthew Ashford) attacked, and killed with a brick by the same cloaked figure that killed Abe.[32][33] It was official, James E. Reilly was crafting a "whodunnit?" murder storyline. Next, viewers saw 34-year veteran recovering alcoholic Maggie Horton (Suzanne Rogers) get bludgeoned to death with a wine bottle.[32][34] The next murder is Caroline Brady(Peggy McCay) who is poisoned.[32][35] Viewers then saw bad girl Cassie Brady (Alexis Thorpe) fall out of a Halloween pinata with stab wounds.[32][36] Marlena's ex-husband, Roman Brady (Josh Taylor) is murdered at his wedding to Kate Roberts.[32][37] At the Horton circus, the serial killer releases a tiger (named Horton), and sets him loose on Tony DiMera.[32][38] Tony is dying at the hospital, and, much to the fans surprise,[39] the killer is revealed to be Marlena.[39] Marlena's next victim is Doug Williams (Bill Hayes) who has been her friend for years. She kills him at Tom Horton's grave after he finds out she is the killer.[32] The most shocking murder occurs shortly after.[40]Alice Horton (Frances Reid) finds a bloody note at her husband's grave with Marlena's name on it. Subsequently, the evil Marlena murders Alice by choking her with her world-renowned donuts.[32][40] Marlena confesses, and is arrested by her husband, John Black. She is shot and killed on the prison rooftop.[32] The storyline allowed Days of our Lives to reach #2 in the Nielsen chart for soaps.
After dwindling ratings again, the show makes its craziest decision yet. All the victims are brought back alive on the tropical Island of Melaswen (New Salem spelled backwards).[41] The fired actors (James Reynolds, Suzanne Rogers, Matthew Ashford, Alexis Thorpe, Josh Taylor, Peggy McCay, Frances Reid, and Deidre Hall) all returned to their original roles. There was also another twist, the killer wasn't Marlena. Stefano DiMera's nephew, Andre (posing as Tony DiMera) had kidnapped them and made Marlena think she was killing off her friends and family.[31] The storyline was incredibly controversial, and garnered the soap a lot of press.[41]”
If Emmerdale does this they will see similar results. I do remember Kate Oates gave an interview a few months back where she spoke against using stories like this to boost ratings so hopefully she sticks to this unless this is a mandate by the network. Also are the ratings share down for Emmerdale? I know the ratings might be down but if the viewing share is unaffected then really the ratings are fine,