Originally Posted by Lizzie Brookes:
“A monster like Hitler who was bigoted and committed mass murder cannot really be compared to a fictional rapist. I know making Dean a rapist was supposed to try and show that all rapists are not necessarily ugly and it's not always "a stranger in an alleyway at night" scenario but I still think if they wanted him to be hated, they should have written him as a stereotypical bad villain like Fin O Connor, Will Savage etc who are easy to hate. By having him genuinely love Stan, Denise etc and showing moments when he is genuinely nice, they have shown there is more to the character than just being a rapist - that he is not a monster and that he could responds to psychiatric treatment/rehabilitation and show guilt and remorse once he has acknowledged to himself what he did.”
I think he does know what he did, look how he lied to Shirley when she asked if Linda had said 'no'? He knew how bad that would look so LIED that she'd never said it.
I actually think it's good that they haven't gone down the stereotypical route. I doubt TPTB intended it but it
has showcased 'victim blaming' (I'm not saying you are by the way, I've read your posts) I wonder how people in charge feel when they look at some of the stuff that's being said on Twitter and if they feel a certain sense of responsibility or if they just don't care as long as people are talking about it?
Regarding Twitter, even if they're young and have had no experience of or indeed realise how serious rape is (or have any empathy it seems) it's highlighting just how girls can have their heads turned by young, good looking lads. Even though they know what he's done to another woman they still let him off and turn on the woman. Just imagine if e.g. a member of One Direction was accused of a sexual assault? I can well imagine the girls turning on the victim calling her derogatory names, saying that she led them on, why would they have to do that when they can have whoever they want so she must be lying etc. It's actually very saddening.
Quote:
“While what Dean did to Linda was horrific, him being beaten up in prison doesn't make it any better. What right do the other prisoners have to judge him when they may be inside or equally violent crimes. Violence cannot be fought with violence. Things just get out of control then - that's partly why Dean had such a massive personality change after his first stint in prison and that was for a non violent crime. I can still be sorry that he was attacked in prison without condoning what he did to Linda. I can still be sorry that he lost his granddad whom he was close to without excusing his crime (which he should have been punished for. I'm not Christian but I do agree that an eye for an eye makes the world go blind.”
This is where I have to disagree. I could have slapped him daft myself when he was whining to his mother "this is what happens to someone accused of rape in prison". Good. He IS a rapist. I'm not saying I would want him beaten to a pulp or dead but someone getting a few punches in and him knowing some of the fear and pain that Linda felt was quite a satisfactory event to me if she's not going to get justice in law.
As for the emotional pain of losing his granddad, I did enjoy Stan and Dean's scenes in the hospital when he sneaked a bit booze to his granddad and you could see the rapport they had but I can't bring myself to care about how Dean feels about Stan dying. It's like I've cut off from him emotionally. Mind I was the same with Ronnie after the baby swap and I've eventually come to quite enjoy her scenes again.
I might have felt differently if he'd actually been convicted got some jail time then came back on the programme a changed man truly apologetic for what he did. But if they're not going down the legal justice route I feel to see how he can pay for his crime? Being cut off from his parents and the rest of his family? Perhaps but he'll have to leave the square then surely?
Quote:
“In Dean's case luckily he only did what he did once and his misogynistic views may have been shaped by his prison experience the first time and his numerous rejections from women - obviously his misogynstic views are not right but I do understand why he may feel resentment towards women -I it's completely different from someone like Finn who was homophobic just because he could be and went on to beat up blessing, try and attack Nancy etc. I'm sorry but I can't hate Dean. I accept that he has mental health problems that need sorting and that he is capable of love - he should have been punished for the crime and rehabilitated but the way he is acted and written just doesn't evoke the same kind of anger I would have for someone like Finn O Connor or Frank Foster.”
Has it ever been said what happened to him the first time he was in prison? I remember him being as angry as hell when he came out and actually throwing Shirley to the ground but as far as I know it's never been gone into in any depth but people assume he's been raped. I'm not saying he hasn't but we've never heard that he was IIRC. It could have just been that being young, pretty and quite soft that he was picked on a lot so it hardened him up hence his attitude and violence to Shirley when he came out. I also remember being bloody annoyed that they wrote the character out right then
just as he was becoming interesting!
Originally Posted by Ell_Ren:
“I would much rather have seen the truth come to light earlier and seen Shirley dealing with the fact that her son raped her other sons wife - to see how that would feel for a mother knowing that - rather than just seeing her blindly defending Dean and shouting the odds. It would have given Linda Henry better material also.”
Me too, I agree.
Originally Posted by eejm:
“I'm thinking we might see more of this later. Shirley obviously realizes - but doesn't want to admit - Linda could be telling the truth about the rape. Shirley seems to be holding on very tightly to the possibility that Dean is being honest when he said it was consensual sex. I still think that she's doing this out of massive guilt for abandoning Dean multiple times, and that she sees that this situation is somehow her fault.
However, we get the idea that Shirley is supporting Dean right now whatever her motives. This story really needs to progress, and soon.”
Half the time nowadays I'm getting the feeling that she's sticking with Dean just to p!ss Mick off! THAT'S how badly it's being written to me.
How Shirley could have any doubts after talking to Linda and seeing that Linda will still not 'back down' about it but also seeing the doubt on Dean's face when she asked if Linda had said 'no' then almost immediately watch him go into self-defence mode by practically blaming HER for what happened amazes me. She MUST know, she's just kidding herself because she doesn't want it to be true. Which mother would? But eventually you have to look at what's staring you in the face.
Originally Posted by bass55:
“Excellent post. As I have said before on this subject, I very much doubt that if Phil or Ian had been the rapist these idiots would be going to such lengths to defend them. But Dean is pretty so it's alright.
I'll give the writers credit for one thing, they really have exposed just how much victim-blaming culture, and in some cases blatant misogyny, is still very much a thing.”
Spot on.
With the victim blaming culture too.
Originally Posted by kitkat1971:
“I'd add impotence into that as well. Mick is powerless to protect Linda from Dean's continued presence (which whether he means it to or not is a torment for Linda) or get him punished. He also probably feels guilty for telling Linda to comfort Dean whilst he was off looking for Shirley.
Plus, he has the head ++++ of having discovered his sister is his mother and he's been dealing with his father dying as well.
Mick isn't helping matters in many ways but why can't people see that his head is in as big a mess as Dean's was the night of the attack? If you have sympathy for one, you must also have it for the other one surely?”
The truth is when people say "you'd think it had happened to HIM" that he
is a victim too. It happened to his wife and he has all sorts of guilt because of it. Like you say he's also been thrown by the fact that Shirley's his mother and his dad wasn't his dad! That's a total headf*** by itself without everything else! But also that he finds out he's got the same dad as his brother who has raped his wife yet his 'parents' are standing shoulder to shoulder with the abuser. And now his 'dad's' just died who had late stage cancer and that's also difficult to deal with by itself without all the rest!
And people wonder why Mick's angry, going around with a face like a smacked mackerel and is ever so slightly p!ssed off?
Originally Posted by
sorcha_healy27:
“Rapists aren't all ugly old men. Rapists can be good looking and charming which can lull their victims into a false sense of security so in a way it is good to portray that.
However they need to end it now. 
”
Very true, and I honestly think that they are the more dangerous ones.
Originally Posted by srhgts:
“Maybe it's just me but I do think "there's that rapist." I mean I've not forgotten what other characters have done and am conscious of their misdeeds, but it's not necessarily always in the forefront like with Dean.”
I think of the rape every time he appears on screen so it's definitely not just you.
Originally Posted by shrinkingviolet:
“Same. And when I see Dean & Shirley I wonder how they're going to rub it in the victims face or martyr themselves over it.
They need to permanently sever the ties between the Vic Carters and Shirley or have them make up. Sadly the ridiculous decision to let Shirley emotionally blackmail herself to a share in the pub means that will never happen. It's just added one more stress onto Mick & Linda in an already ridiculously stressful time, which ofc makes people whine even more about them being miserable. It's all a bit of a vicious circle right now.”
Agreed. Good post.