IMO it appeared to me that she thought it was embarassing because he's not thin and cool and said no to him. Then, she said no to an old man playing the bongos, again saying it's not cool. Then appears a large group of cool youths dancing and she loves it.

To be honest, I thought it was unfair to buzz him, she just said it wasn't up to standard as the others, but buzzing him was cruel, it's not like he was terrible.

And I know this opinion will be unpopular

It was unfair putting him through. Making him think he has a talent that he clearly does not. If I was a skinny kid they would have all buzzed.

he was having some swagger fun from his fav artist Beyonce..but he won't get through to the lives, let's be honest

And maybe a feeling he had no friends!, he not get past the next round.

The kid was likable, but his "dancing" routine was terrible. Amanda and David, I can understand, but Simon would normally buzz an act like that, and rarely stands up to give anyone a standing ovation.

They probably felt sorry for the kid. Overweight, and probably gets picked on all the time. Sixteen years old, and not visited anywhere outside Ireland till now - it would be cruel if they didn't make it a pleasurable experience.

Agreed - he got through solely on the fat vote. Bloody ridiculous.