• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Big Brother
The Public think that Harriet is better looking than Jade, Adjoa and the Twins
<<
<
4 of 4
>>
>
Seveneyes
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by ForGodsSake:
“Jade and the twins are vain which, to me, takes away some of their "good looks".”

And ill bet no model agency has ever used that as a factor...for good reason.
eva_prior
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Veri:
“The problem with all of that is that Jade is obviously beautiful. The idea that she is "not in the least bit pretty" is odd, to say the least.

It's very common, however, for people to say a beautiful woman they dislike isn't beautiful. I have seen it many times. It doesn't always happen, but it is very common. People who say it may even genuinely believe the woman isn't beautiful; but that doesn't make them right.

It's not true that the public don't think she's beautiful. The public have not been asked, and people who vote in one of the BB app polls can have a variety of different motives, as we've discussed in this thread.”

No.. You perceive her to be 'obviously beautiful.'

Some other viewers don't.
Veri
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by fifitrixibelle:
“But you are insisting your view on 'beauty' is the only one.....why not take it as read that not everyone share's what you perceive as beautiful......I don't think she's in the least bit beautiful...I wouldn't even say she was pretty,,and I'm stumped as to how both she and other's could consider that she is anything but average at best, but that's life, it doesn't make either view right or wrong or not 'genuine'.”

I'm not insisting (or even saying) that my view on 'beauty' (why the quotes?) is the only one. But, unlike (it seems) people who believe beauty is in the eye of the beholder, I distinguish between all of the following.

1. How beautiful someone is.

2. How beautiful someone is according to the currently prevailing 'standards' in some time and place (such as the UK, now).

3. How much someone's looks appeal to me personally.

I can have an opinion on (1) and (2), but that opinion is still distinct from (3).

If we were discussing how intelligent HMs were, I don't think people would be making the sort of accusation you've making there. They wouldn't be saying things like "not everyone share's what you perceive as intelligent". I think beauty and intelligence are in quite similar 'boats'.
Veri
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by eva_prior:
“No.. You perceive her to be 'obviously beautiful.'

Some other viewers don't.”

I don't "perceive her to be 'obviously beautiful'". How would that even work?
eva_prior
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Veri:
“I don't "perceive her to be 'obviously beautiful'". How would that even work? ”

You made that statement in your post. So clearly, that is how you perceive Jade?
Seveneyes
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by eva_prior:
“No.. You perceive her to be 'obviously beautiful.'

Some other viewers don't.”

And I would agree with you she isn't full on obvious beauty,but in the fashion/modelling world she has that blank slate beauty that they LOVE,they can manipulate her (more than any other housemate) to look beautiful and DIFFERENT in nearly every shoot,to me Sarah is more obviously beautiful but it's only going to be one 'look' more or less...Jade has endless possibilities, she would get the gig EVERY time...

I used to love ANTM
Veri
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by eva_prior:
“You made that statement in your post. So clearly, that is how you perceive Jade?”

Where did I supposedly make the statement that I perceive her to be obviously beautiful?

What would that even mean?
eva_prior
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Veri:
“Where did I supposedly make the statement that I perceive her to be obviously beautiful?

What would that even mean?”

OK Veri - I'm gonna opt out with you.
eva_prior
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Seveneyes:
“And I would agree with you she isn't full on obvious beauty,but in the fashion/modelling world she has that blank slate beauty that they LOVE,they can manipulate her (more than any other housemate) to look beautiful and DIFFERENT in nearly every shoot,to me Sarah is more obviously beautiful but it's only going to be one 'look' more or less...Jade has endless possibilities, she would get the gig EVERY time...

I used to love ANTM ”

Agreed -Jade is perceived by SOME people in the fashion/modeling industry as an 'obvious beauty' and by SOME viewers/posters as 'obviously beautiful.'

However, it's equally the case, that Jade is NOT perceived by SOME people in the fashion/modeling industry as an 'obvious beauty;' and NOT perceived by SOME viewers/posters as 'obviously beautiful.'

What is ANTM?
Seveneyes
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by eva_prior:
“Agreed -Jade is perceived by SOME people in the fashion/modeling industry as an 'obvious beauty' and by SOME viewers/posters as 'obviously beautiful.'

However, more importantly (in the context of this discussion):

Jade is NOT perceived by SOME people in the fashion/modeling industry as an 'obvious beauty;' and NOT perceived by some viewers/posters as 'obviously beautiful.'

What is ANTM?”

America's Next Top Model

But I don't think youve quite grasped what I tried to explain, no matter
Scarlet O'Hara
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by patsylimerick:
“But those jaws!

Sorry - but they're channeling Bruce Forsythe for me.”

I've been racking my brain trying to work out who they remind me of. And it's Skylar (Anna Gunn) from Breaking Bad, precisely because of the jaw. These arent the best pics but see what I mean?

https://postmediaprovince.files.word...a_gunn-web.jpg

http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/...20150407000738
Originally Posted by patsylimerick:
“I think if you're sat at home and you look a bit like Harriet and you're 17 or 18 the temptation is to vote for Harriet as the most attractive because it is, in a way, self-affirming to then watch the results come in and watch someone who looks like you being named most attractive. That's the same reason why you wouldn't vote for Sarah, or Jade, or Adjoa or the twins; because you feel they're better-looking than you and you wouldn't get that nice, warm, fuzzy feeling when Ms. Normal wins the crown.

It's why all those 'ugly duckling' chick flicks do so well at the Box Office. You have to leave your brain in the foyer, of course, to ignore the fact that the 'ugly duckling' was a thinly disguised stunner to begin with. ”

Brilliant.
eva_prior
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Seveneyes:
“America's Next Top Model

But I don't think youve quite grasped what I tried to explain, no matter ”

Agh - thanks for the explanation.

Full of head-cold....so you MAY be right!
jp761
20-05-2015
No they don't they vote on who they like and don't like mainly. Saying fu** you to the actual question in front of them lol
Seveneyes
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Scarlet O'Hara:
“I've been racking my brain trying to work out who they remind me of. And it's Skylar (Anna Gunn) from Breaking Bad, precisely because of the jaw. These arent the best pics but see what I mean?



Brilliant. ”

Haha...YES Skylar!!
How didn't I see it before?? Nice one Scarlet
Seveneyes
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by eva_prior:
“Agh - thanks for the explanation.

Full of head-cold....so you MAY be right!”

Orr ...hope your feeling better soon

Lemsips,brandy a bowl of steaming hot water and a towel...get your head in the steam
fifitrixibelle
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Veri:
“I'm not insisting (or even saying) that my view on 'beauty' (why the quotes?) is the only one. But, unlike (it seems) people who believe beauty is in the eye of the beholder, I distinguish between all of the following.

1. How beautiful someone is.

2. How beautiful someone is according to the currently prevailing 'standards' in some time and place (such as the UK, now).

3. How much someone's looks appeal to me personally.

I can have an opinion on (1) and (2), but that opinion is still distinct from (3).

If we were discussing how intelligent HMs were, I don't think people would be making the sort of accusation you've making there. They wouldn't be saying things like "not everyone share's what you perceive as intelligent". I think beauty and intelligence are in quite similar 'boats'.”

1 + 3 are other way's of saying that beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder ....not sure why you insist Jade being 'obviously beautiful' is a fact because she meets your criteria..she isn't to me...small, uneven eyes and a rather 'weak' face is what I see.....clearly you see something else, Adjoa has those and that is why I find her beautiful.
CLL Dodge
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Jane_Lee3:
“IMHO, Harriet is cute and quite pretty and comes across as rather ordinary; THAT is why she appeals to folk I think. My other half thinks she is adorable.!!! ”

I would agree with "cute" being an apt term. That doesn't quite compensate for her personality which I find less appealing.
patsylimerick
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Scarlet O'Hara:
“I've been racking my brain trying to work out who they remind me of. And it's Skylar (Anna Gunn) from Breaking Bad, precisely because of the jaw. These arent the best pics but see what I mean?

https://postmediaprovince.files.word...a_gunn-web.jpg

http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/...20150407000738


Brilliant. ”

Ah, so they do! Love Breaking Bad! Great spot
trevor tiger
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by Scarlet O'Hara:
“I've been racking my brain trying to work out who they remind me of. And it's Skylar (Anna Gunn) from Breaking Bad, precisely because of the jaw. These arent the best pics but see what I mean?

https://postmediaprovince.files.word...a_gunn-web.jpg

http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/...20150407000738


Brilliant. ”

Oh yes you're right I never did think Skylar was particularly good looking which might explain why the twins don't appeal to me.

As for Jade being a model, as odd as it sounds, models aren't always classically beautiful and maybe not attractive at all in many ways. I think Jade like Kate Moss is sexy rather than classically beautiful. I do maintain that Adjoa is classically beautiful and I also maintain that those who voted refused to acknowledge Adjoa's beauty because she has been cast as the villain despite her not doing anything particularly villainous
Veri
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by fifitrixibelle:
“1 + 3 are other way's of saying that beauty is indeed in the eye of the beholder ....not sure why you insist Jade being 'obviously beautiful' is a fact because she meets your criteria..she isn't to me...small, uneven eyes and a rather 'weak' face is what I see.....clearly you see something else, Adjoa has those and that is why I find her beautiful.”

It's only the 'beauty' in (3) that's in the eye of the individual beholder. When people say beauty's in the eye of the beholder these days, they're not talking about a 'standard' (so to speak) that was different historically or in different cultures; they're making beauty be a matter of each individual's own, personal reaction. That makes it different from (2). And in (1) the beauty is independent even of cultural or historical 'standards'. (Many people would reject the idea that there is any way for beauty to be that 'objective'; but even if the idea is rejected, it's still a different idea from (2) or (3).)

If my earlier post wasn't clear on what I meant in (1), I hope this post makes it clearer. I thought that saying I think beauty and intelligence were in quite similar 'boats' would help make things clearer, but perhaps not.

Anyway, I didn't insist or say anything was a fact or say anything about any personal criteria of my own I might have.

It seems to me that most people can, if they want, distinguish between how attractive or appealing they personally find someone's looks and whether the person is beautiful, even if they sometimes use the word "beautiful" in both cases. None of the women in this BB have looks that appeal very much to me.
Veri
20-05-2015
Originally Posted by trevor tiger:
“Oh yes you're right I never did think Skylar was good looking which might explain why the twins don't appeal to me.

As for Jade being a model, as odd as it sounds, models aren't always classically beautiful and maybe not attractive at all in many ways. I think Jade like Kate Moss is sexy rather than classically beautiful. I do maintain that Adjoa is classically beautiful and I also maintain that those who voted refused to acknowledge Adjoa's beauty because she has been cast as the villain despite her not doing anything particularly villainous ”

Kate Moss isn't classically beautiful, but she didn't have typical model looks either. She's so successful for so long that it's partly redefined what models look like (and what people think of as a model look). There used to be talk of Kate Moss bringing in a "new ideal of beauty".
Captain Kipper
20-05-2015
I don't like Harriet's eyes, they are not attractive in the slightest.
<<
<
4 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map