Originally Posted by Sarahsaurus:
“I would agree with most of these,but not the last one. The last one isn't guessable,you can't even make an educated guess at it. Only the right answer will fit the two clues,there are highly unlikely to be any plausible wrong answers. So unless you get the right answer,you either have to say something that fits one of the clues (but almost certainly doesn't fit the other),or just say,"I don't know",or "pass." Sometimes I think people will say an answer they know is almost certainly wrong,just to be seen to be saying something.
If you don't have a lot of time to think,there are worse things than saying an answer which you know is almost certainly going to be wrong. It's the same as a pass (except on Mastermind).
I remember on Mastermind years ago somebody went on it and if they didn't know an answer they just said something like "Arsenal",no matter what the question was about. The idea was to have no passes,which count against you if it's a tie. But if you give a wrong answer the host takes up time giving the right answer,whereas if you pass he moves straight on to the next question. So it's debatable if the "no passing" strategy is effective.”
True, I agree that the 2 clues one isn't guessable besides the correct answer. I mean I can only imagine how difficult it is for a contestant, having very little time to think of an answer and feeling the pressure, compared to people sitting at home. I guess not all of the stupid answers are stupid because the contestant is stupid, but at the end of the day that doesn't matter a jot to the editor of Private Eye and the mass amount of people reading the Dumb Britain section.
And interesting about Mastermind, as that seems to be about the only show that adopts such rules as that. In most others the host always gives the correct answers even if they pass. I think saying pass is the best way for a lot of questions which ask for an answer from a vast group of long winded answers like a song title or name of a book... but it's amazing the amount of people who pass on questions where they're asked for an answer from a small set like a star sign, decade or ocean.