The others were all laughing. Harriet was laughing too, but she pushed Aaron onto Joel so she is also culpable, I think she should be out as well .
Why wasn't Harriet removed too
2 of 2
Originally Posted by i am god:
“because she dident break a rule just a thought”
“because she dident break a rule just a thought”
Exactly.
We go through the same thing every year; people wanting housemates removed for spurious reasons, simply because they don't like them.
They have to have broken a rule before they are ejected.
Originally Posted by Karen_Annanina:
“The theme of the Jodie Foster movie about a gang rape, "The Accused" is that onlookers who egg on the perpetrators DO share legal culpability. So it could be argued that Harriet should have received SOME kind of sanction.”
“The theme of the Jodie Foster movie about a gang rape, "The Accused" is that onlookers who egg on the perpetrators DO share legal culpability. So it could be argued that Harriet should have received SOME kind of sanction.”
Exactly.
Originally Posted by i am god:
“because she dident break a rule just a thought”
“because she dident break a rule just a thought”
She pushed Aaron in to Joel.
Originally Posted by threecheeses:
“She should have received a warning for being an accessory”
“She should have received a warning for being an accessory”
Like a handbag or bracelet?
Originally Posted by benbeez1:
“she'll be removed on Friday by the public, so why would channel 5 miss out on loads of 50p's coming their way”
“she'll be removed on Friday by the public
, so why would channel 5 miss out on loads of 50p's coming their way”
Haha ... exactly
Originally Posted by Bowdon:
“No. Ultimately everyone is responsible for their OWN actions.
Yes Harriet's behaviour wasnt good. But she wasn't the one going too far.”
“No. Ultimately everyone is responsible for their OWN actions.
Yes Harriet's behaviour wasnt good. But she wasn't the one going too far.”
I agree. Aaron's an adult, he is responsible for his own actions. She may have encouraged and goaded him, but he didn't have to do as she said. She wasn't the only person encouraging either, as they all said to Joel on the clip shown on BOTS - they all agree they were egging Aaron on.
Originally Posted by docman:
“She pushed Aaron in to Joel.”
“She pushed Aaron in to Joel.”
Nobody is saying that she is blameless. But Aaron was booted because he continually followed and harassed Joel.
I think most of the house mates misread the situation. Some of Joels mannerism's are quirky and I think they thought it was funny in how he was dealing with the situation, so laughed. Harriet took it another step further. But ultimately Aaron is responsible for his own actions.
I believe Harriet should receive a warning, she pushed Aaron onto Joel and was also the one making the thrusting movements egging him on.
Originally Posted by Karen_Annanina:
“The theme of the Jodie Foster movie about a gang rape, "The Accused" is that onlookers who egg on the perpetrators DO share legal culpability. So it could be argued that Harriet should have received SOME kind of sanction.”
“The theme of the Jodie Foster movie about a gang rape, "The Accused" is that onlookers who egg on the perpetrators DO share legal culpability. So it could be argued that Harriet should have received SOME kind of sanction.”
your basically saying harriet was involved in a gang rape wow ,the anti harriet brigade have gone to a whloe new level of desperate
Originally Posted by muggins14:
“Like a handbag or bracelet?
.”
“Like a handbag or bracelet?
.”
No, quite clearly they are accessories to Aaron's actions.
They all should have had a good speaking to about their behaviour.
is this the new age of puritanism sweeping the uk. lets punish everyone for improper thoughts next. the whole thing is ridiculous and aaron shouldnt have been kicked out. now its harriets fault. 
2 of 2
