Ashley was much better.

Jules made a dog walk a tightrope. I'd like to see Ashley make Pudsey do that.

Ashleigh for me. I mean, Jules was good too, but being the original, Ashleigh had the "wow" factor. Added to that, she was still a kid when she trained Pudsey to do what he did.

They are both brilliant, I cant pick one over the other.

Something of a difference as Ashleigh is more pure dance but Jules is more narrative silent comedy.

I don't like dogs being humanised and not a fan of dancing dogs and so to that end I'm not keen on Ashleigh and Pudsey ( though I do recognise the high level of skill and bond between the two) but could watch Jules and Matisse over and over. I find Ashleigh and Pudsey a bit saccharine and gag worthy personally. My only downer on Jules and Matisse was that using 3 legged Skippy for sympathy votes was a bit of a cheap trick.

I prefer Jules, the routines are way better and I could watch them again and enjoy them. I think it's just the fact that Ashleigh and Pudsey are more of a dancing dog act whereas Jules and Matisse do sketches.

I think Ashleigh's personality came over a bit more than Jules's

So did Pudsey!
Look again at his performances, they all had a story

I think Ashleigh was the better human element of both acts but Matisse the better dog

More theme than story, difference.

Ashlegh at least she danced with Pudsey