Originally Posted by alancracker:
“I am one of FTs biggest critics in terms of his attitude later in his spell at LFC and the manner of his leaving - but I do think at his best (the first 2 seasons) he deserves to be in and stick by my choice - as you rightly say it's all about opinions and we both have the right to ours!!
Fowler? - again awesome in his early LFC career (late 90s) but after injury was never the same and so when we had him, MO and Heskey he could not get in the team (and I felt that was correct as the other 2 were playing better). At Leeds, City and in his second spell with us he never got back to his early levels. What I do love about Robbie tho is his love of LFC which is up there with our best ever legends and if Klopp gave him a coaching role I would be all for it and I think he would do a good job.
Misawa? - in Rafas reign CFC were already in their mega bucks period with Jose at the helm - once he left Porto it is clear that he is never going to work for a club without mega bucks!! - so for us to have the quality of players we had (Masch, Torres, Alonso ...etc) was good managing by Rafa especially in terms of recruitment (the Spanish link helped) but I do accept he bought a lot of duds too.”
The 2008/09 squad that Rafa built was the best we've had in the last 20 years or so.
GK - Reina - at the time was top quality
FB - Arbeloa, Finnan & Aurelio - Finnan and Aurelio were great going forward, all 3 were terrific defensively and Arbeloa could play on both sides.
CD - Hyypia, Skrtel, Agger and Carragher - Again, 4 great centre backs. Who can forget that 1-4 game at Old Trafford when Hyypia came in at the last minute and gave an almighty performance
CM -Alonso, Mascherano, Gerrard and Lucas - 3 world class midfielders and at their peak years, was a midfield almost every team would have wanted at the time.
F - Kuyt, Riera, Babel, Benayoun and Torres - Only Babel didn't live up to expectations, although he did score the winner against United at Anfield. Riera and Benayoun were brilliant, Kuyt was Kuyt and Torres was the best number 9 in the world at that time.
It was a real shame that by the next season we had lost Arbeloa, Alonso and Hyypia. Finnan, Riera and Benayoun seemed to fall out favour for some reason. Mascherano's heart wasn't in it anymore - it just went to pieces.