What a real talent Lucie Silvas is.

IMO "What You're Made Of" is up there with the best. Kelly Clarkson, Fantasia Barrino are mere pygmies in comparison.

BTW this weeks idol was appallingly bad. Simon Cowell looked well PO and will need to slap that weasel Seacrest.

Out.

Eh? Was Lucie on American Idol or something?

Lucie Silvas better than Kelly Clarkson...not even in or close to being the same league as Kelly. You can't compare and post in music section the next time.

"Eh? Was Lucie on American Idol or something?"
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dahhh? No Lucie did not appear on that dreadful show. I was simply comparing real British talent with a bunch of talentless yanks. With the acception of Bo & Carrie this years idol is a complete washout.

I like Lucie Silvas, and also Kelly Clarkson. They're not really very similar singers though.

Have to agree with you there but sorry Kelly and Fantasia can outsing Lucie with ease and are megastars compared to her but Lucie is a better songwriter thats the only aspect she is better in.

Yeah Lucy is brilliant. A musical genius in the making

lucie's name shouldn't be mentioned in the same sentence as kelly-enough said.go kelly!

Hey? What has Lucie Silvas got to do with American Idol???

For the sake or random comparison though, how about "Well none of the contestants on AI are a patch on Morrissey".

Hey! Since we're talkin about random stuff... I must comment how,in my opinion, American Idol will never compare to the 80's British Music... The Cure, Depeche Mode(sigh)... perhaps that is why I had to move here!!!

the banshees...Gary numan....soft cell...thompson twins....tears for fears...Heaven 17...ahhh those golden years

....in a roundabout way she's involved in reality TV shows. Although she's a friend of the blonde one from The 411, she's written songs for Liberty X (Jumpin'), Gareth Gates, Michelle McManus (and Rachel Stevens).

A bit like Christina Milian in the fact she's had to write a whole load of stuff for other people before the record company were willing to give her a chance of performing and having an album deal.

Good on her. But I'm not particularly fond of her music.

Stereoman:

I admire you for your effort but lets face it the link, at best, is somewhat tedious!!!