Originally Posted by
WhiteLady:
“Hello there! I haven't posted on DS for such a long time, but Alrightmate may remember me! Anyway, just wanted to add this little thought to all of your brilliant theories and bits of info. Going back to the 1st episode, at the end where the Doctor comes back for Rose, I thought of 2 ideas.
1) A lot has happened to the Doctor before he comes back, say the time loop theory, or the events mentioned in the series that he's seen, the sinking of the Titanic, JFK's murder and all that. He realises something about Rose or about how important it is to have a companion, so goes back just after the time he's just left her, to really try and convince her to come along with him, whereas the first time he asked was just a polite request.
2) If you're buying into an imposter/Master theory, then the Doctor that came back for her wasn't the real Doctor, he'd tracked the real Doctor and materialised just as the real Doctor left, because he knows something about Rose's importance again, and knew after her encounter with him and the Autons, she'd trust him, or something like that.
Anyway, that's probably all nonsense but I thought it may be a little useful to the discussion, carry on folks, very entertained by the show and this thread!
”
Hi Whitelady,
Yes I remember you. Good to see you.
1) Yes, I also said that a lot could of happened before we saw The Doctor when I suggested that Chris Eccleston doesn't necessarily have to be the 9th Doctor, and as we didn't see him regenerate from Paul McGann it's still open that he could be a future Doctor. David Tennant could be who Paul McGann regenerates into.
But I'm not saying I'm going with this. It's just an option that's still open. I doubt if it is correct though.
But yes, he could have been running around for years before meeting Rose, so anything could have happened in that time.
2) I also considered this option, that when The Doctor first leaves Rose crestfallen that she couldn't come with him, and when he comes back he might not be the real Doctor.
I just discarded that idea though.
Because I'm coming round to the belief that the Tardis is controlling his actions. Because that option fits in with some of what we have already witnessed thus far.
And I'm not ready to fully embrace the idea that The Doctor is The Master anymore. Not until we have a few clues as to point to that first.
I'm going away from the idea that it's a "Bad" Doctor anymore, as I am leaning more towards the idea that it is a "Bad" Tardis instead.
Good to see you here. hope you stick around.