Originally Posted by The Dandy:
“Where to begin?”
Yes, where to begin with bullies and apologists for bullys, with blindly rule-following slaves?
Quote:
“Why should everyone have to have a go at wading in fish guts, for example? It's perfectly reasonable to object to that.
Eh no, being asked to skin a kitten would've been objectionable, the guy was squeamy.”
Of course it's reasonable to object to fish guts. More HMs should object to more things. The Celebs in the most recent Celeb BB, for example. BB had no business making them -- especially the older ones -- sit around in the cold and damp, or, indeed, spinning them around to make them vomit.
Quote:
“Now, if he had gone into the Diary Room and said calmly:
For religious reasons I cannot do this task then I would've been fine with it.”
I wonder. I suspect you'd have doubted that there really were religious reasons.
In any case, no one needs a grand reason like that.
Quote:
“He was told what all the tasks would be, was he?
Nooo, because that would have rather spoiled the game now wouldn't it?”
So he didn't know "what was expected of him when he agreed to take part in the show". None of them signed up in advance for whatever BB decided to throw at them. Ever hear of informed consent? People need to know what they're agreeing to, and not just in vague, general terms, for them to really be agreeing to it.
We're getting near to the ridiculous Davina line that because the HMs were told to "expect the unexpected" they lose all right to object to anything.
Quote:
“But he would've been alerted to the fact that some of the tasks would not be physically pleasant (if you can find a copy of the memo allegedly sent by Tickle to his mates before he went into the house, then you'll see that they were forewarned the tasks would sometimes be unpleasant).”
So what? "Physically unpleasant" covers a lot of ground. Being alerted to that possibility does not constitute agreement to arbitrary unpleasantness.
Indeed, it's doubtful that the HMs had any reason to believe the tasks were going to be significantly more unpleasant than in earlier BBs. That Jon was warned of "physically unpleasant" tasks for BB4 suggests that "physically unpleasant" can mean things that are quite mild.