Oh, I don't know - it's widely recognised as a great steaming turd of a song.

Thanks for that.

You're confusing the posting of a not-so-popular opinion with trolling.

Love this book. I read it over and over again for years then found the updated 3rd version
which had loads more in it. I am planning to get the Tune In book but am wary as it seems
like a major task. Revolution in the Head is great because you can skip about looking up
specific songs as you fancy.


As mentioned by others this is part of the Abbey Road medley although for years it was my
favourite song so I would say can be listened to in isolation (at least along with Carry That Weight).
That said it works best in context which is the case for many of their songs. I would suggest
listening to some of the albums (especially later ones) in full. That way you might get something
out of some songs you wouldn't by listening to individual songs, The Abbey Road medley
and certain parts of the White Album are especially notable for this. If you are not a big fan
you probably won't get as much out of it (which is fine btw ) but you never know.

Underrated - Tomorrow Never Knows
Overrated - Ob La Di Ob La Da

I don't think Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da was ever rated

Even John himself apparently loathed the song

Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da was pure McCartney musical fluff.. John had no hand in writing it., and would never have been associated with it despite the Lennon/McCartney tag..

As far as being overrated is concerned, the pop group Marmalade had a top 10 hit with it in the late 60s and it was constantly played on the radio ad nauseam, so I think it well qualifies.

Thanks for your input on this. I've occasionally discovered what has eventually become some of my favourite music via recommendations of others so...I made a visit to my local library earlier, which generally has an excellent CD section. I think they had every single Beatles CD possible except..... Abbey Road. But that probably just means its checked out elsewhere at present so I'll try again next week. I did pick up the White Album though, which aside from a few obvious tracks I don't know at all, so will load that onto the ipod and take a listen.

I also got McCartney's 'Band On The Run' album as someone else I was discussing all this with highly recommended it.

Band on the Run is the only McCartney album I listen to with any regularity. There's some good tracks on other albums but let down by the heap of dross along with them IMO.

Underated - She said She said
Overrated - Hey Jude

That somewhat echoes other opinions I've heard. I listened to "Band On The Run" whilst out walking earlier. On first hearing, loved it, that one's definitely a 'keeper'.

I also listened to "The White Album" but I'm going to reserve judgement on that for the time being as my initial thoughts were that it's an album you probably need to hear a good few times before offering up any relevant thoughts on it.

overrated - Help.
Underrated - Here comes the sun.

Just take in George Martin's opinion that it would have made a very good single album.

The White Album does sag at points with a few tracks that are unusually weak. It also ends
badly with Revolution 9 more of interest historically than an easy listen while Good Night is
in Lennon's own rather understated words "possibly over lush". Incidentally he wrote that
one not McCartney as many assume. Personally I don't think it should have been one album
but I do think they could have dropped a few (e.g. Piggies or Don't Pass Me By) and added
other songs they had such as Hey Bulldog or kept back The Inner Light for it.

I would say Side 3 is the strongest as I think all songs on that side are great. Sides 1 and 2
I think start and end well but sag in the middle. There are some very clever moves in terms
of album structure when you consider how the songs were written. E.g. Martha My Dear
flows into I'm So Tired as if this was always planned but I don't believe it was. Apparently
Martin, Lennon, and McCartney spent a full 24 hour session putting the track listing together.
Presumably with a few other things to tidy it up but still a mammoth effort.

Michelle is a quality track, so underrated