• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Soaps
Emmerdale - How many times has Robert Sugden been beat up?
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
Mr Men
19-07-2015
His facial structure must be a mess, tedious now?
Crooked Heart
19-07-2015
1. Well, his brother punched him not long after he returned.
2. Then Aaron accidentally hit him in the Home Farm raid.
3. Then I think Ross hit him after the raid.
4. He had a fight with Andy on Andy's stag night.
5. Chrissie slapped him because she thought he was watching porn.
6. He let Aaron beat him up in the road.
7. Cain knocked him out at Vic & Adam's wedding.
8. Then Cain beat him to a pulp
(I've probably missed a few punches and slaps here and there )

Maybe little Jack & Sarah will end up battering him to death with their lunch boxes after finding out he killed their stepmother
abrightyz
19-07-2015
i blame his bad decisions on the number of times he's been battered.. poor baby
Crooked Heart
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by abrightyz:
“i blame his bad decisions on the number of times he's been battered.. poor baby ”

Indeed. His poor frontal lobes!
KNs47
19-07-2015
If South Park can have 'Who Killed Kenny?' then Emmerdale can hit back with 'Who Beat Up Robert?'!
Mr Men
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Crooked Heart:
“1. Well, his brother punched him not long after he returned.
2. Then Aaron accidentally hit him in the Home Farm raid.
3. Then I think Ross hit him after the raid.
4. He had a fight with Andy on Andy's stag night.
5. Chrissie slapped him because she thought he was watching porn.
6. He let Aaron beat him up in the road.
7. Cain knocked him out at Vic & Adam's wedding.
8. Then Cain beat him to a pulp
(I've probably missed a few punches and slaps here and there )

Maybe little Jack & Sarah will end up battering him to death with their lunch boxes after finding out he killed their stepmother ”

Ross Barton beats him up next week!
Janet Plank
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Mr Men:
“Ross Barton beats him up next week!”



Another patient for the BHW (Bashed Head Ward)) at Hotton General. It would be nice to go visiting the hospital one day and find Ross in that ward.
cyrilandshirley
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Crooked Heart:
“1. Well, his brother punched him not long after he returned.
2. Then Aaron accidentally hit him in the Home Farm raid.
3. Then I think Ross hit him after the raid.
4. He had a fight with Andy on Andy's stag night.
5. Chrissie slapped him because she thought he was watching porn.
6. He let Aaron beat him up in the road.
7. Cain knocked him out at Vic & Adam's wedding.
8. Then Cain beat him to a pulp
(I've probably missed a few punches and slaps here and there )

Maybe little Jack & Sarah will end up battering him to death with their lunch boxes after finding out he killed their stepmother ”

This would make the most amazing montage.

He's a real popular guy.
ME1234567
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Crooked Heart:
“1. Well, his brother punched him not long after he returned.
2. Then Aaron accidentally hit him in the Home Farm raid.
3. Then I think Ross hit him after the raid.
4. He had a fight with Andy on Andy's stag night.
5. Chrissie slapped him because she thought he was watching porn.
6. He let Aaron beat him up in the road.
7. Cain knocked him out at Vic & Adam's wedding.
8. Then Cain beat him to a pulp
(I've probably missed a few punches and slaps here and there )

Maybe little Jack & Sarah will end up battering him to death with their lunch boxes after finding out he killed their stepmother ”

Katie slapped him too after the thing with the rings
Mr Men
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Janet Plank:
“[/b]
Another patient for the BHW (Bashed Head Ward)) at Hotton General. It would be nice to go visiting the hospital one day and find Ross in that ward.”

Robert would be very popular on Hollyoaks!

Scheming, check!
Good looking, check!
Bisexual bed hopper, check!
Always in need of medical need aka any excuse to feature the comedy hospital, he wouldn't have a chance against the Gloved Hand Killer he would be there that often, check!

He just needs to be hugged gay by Ste Hay and get some facial hair and he would bewan 'Oaks legend!
cyrilandshirley
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Mr Men:
“
He just needs to be hugged gay by Ste Hay and get some facial hair and he would bewan 'Oaks legend!”

To be honest, I was a massive Brendan fan, and I've been getting definite vibes recently that the ED writers have been raiding the Brendan Brady handbook of villainy. There are definite similarities in the delight with which they manipulate other people - Rob's just much more of a physical coward.

Robert with a tache would look incredible, but I suspect he'd look more like a WW1 pilot than a porn star.
lulu g
19-07-2015
They may be trying to make him a Brendan Brady Mk II, but he is no Brendan Brady.
Crooked Heart
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by cyrilandshirley:
“To be honest, I was a massive Brendan fan, and I've been getting definite vibes recently that the ED writers have been raiding the Brendan Brady handbook of villainy. There are definite similarities in the delight with which they manipulate other people - Rob's just much more of a physical coward.

★Robert with a tache would look incredible★, but I suspect he'd look more like a WW1 pilot than a porn star. ”

★...★: I think they would have to stick a false one on him! Robert doesn't look like he needs to shave that often

*Chocks away!*

Mr Men
19-07-2015
Robert is better. Brendan became daft to watch eventually.
cyrilandshirley
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Mr Men:
“Robert is better. Brendan became daft to watch eventually.”

You thought the stuff about Brendan's abused childhood was daft? I thought it was amazing.

Anyway, it's not a competition. I loved watching Brendan, and I love watching Robert. They have similarities and differences. I hope one day they might explore a bit more why Robert is the totally selfish bastard he is. They might do that in the big face-off with Andy I guess, but I won't hold my breath.
soap-lea
19-07-2015
not enough in my opinion... nurobert is terrible
ME1234567
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by lulu g:
“They may be trying to make him a Brendan Brady Mk II, but he is no Brendan Brady.”

I guess i can see some similarities but they are completely different imo.
Crooked Heart
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by cyrilandshirley:
“You thought the stuff about Brendan's abused childhood was daft? I thought it was amazing.

Anyway, it's not a competition. I loved watching Brendan, and I love watching Robert. They have similarities and differences. ★I hope one day they might explore a bit more why Robert is the totally selfish bastard he is★. They might do that in the big face-off with Andy I guess, but I won't hold my breath.”

★...★: We may find out something by the end of next week.
Spoiler
Paddy and Aaron don't report him to the police after what he does, so something must happen. Maybe it's because Aaron will end up in prison too that they don't, but I don't think Aaron would care about that (he's steaming with rage in the preview And Rob looks terrified ). So Rob must either tell them something(I'm hoping it's this and it's something really jaw dropping! ) or they'll tell him he's got a couple of weeks to sort himself out and then he has to leave for good(which I think is more likely and a bit disappointing).
Mr Men
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Crooked Heart:
“★...★: We may find out something by the end of next week.
Spoiler
Paddy and Aaron don't report him to the police after what he does, so something must happen. Maybe it's because Aaron will end up in prison too that they don't, but I don't think Aaron would care about that (he's steaming with rage in the preview And Rob looks terrified ). So Rob must either tell them something(I'm hoping it's this and it's something really jaw dropping! ) or they'll tell him he's got a couple of weeks to sort himself out and then he has to leave for good(which I think is more likely and a bit disappointing).
”

He tells Aaron he pushed Katie.


Originally Posted by cyrilandshirley:
“You thought the stuff about Brendan's abused childhood was daft? I thought it was amazing.

Anyway, it's not a competition. I loved watching Brendan, and I love watching Robert. They have similarities and differences. I hope one day they might explore a bit more why Robert is the totally selfish bastard he is. They might do that in the big face-off with Andy I guess, but I won't hold my breath.”

Beating his lover which was deemed acceptable by many a fan. However when straight man Patrick Blake hits Maxine Minniver it is wrong.

He murdered and that to was ok because he was sexually abused and confused.

His one sided fued with Warren Fox despite that character being a big reason people started to take the show seriously, aka a fickle fanbase.
Silas Blissett has to be one of the shows best villains with Warren in it to at the same time. However low and behold he gets shoehorned into his plot and made out he was the better character.

His ending was pathetic as they couldn't be brave enough to kill him off.
ME1234567
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by soap-lea:
“not enough in my opinion... nurobert is terrible”

I disagree,
Crooked Heart
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Mr Men:
“He tells Aaron he pushed Katie.”

I know.
Spoiler
That would give Paddy and Aaron another reason(plus he shoots Paddy!) to go to the police. But they don't. They all end up in the pub the next day(with Paddy's arm in a sling). So why not? Either he must tell them something about himself or his past which shocks them, or there's the theory he might turn the gun on himself, or they give him some ultimatum e.g. leave soon and never come back and we won't tell! Or some other reason I can't think of Aaron looks incandescent with rage(apparently he takes Rob to the isolated lodge with the intention of getting a confession and then to literally kill him ) so I don't think it'll be a case of not saying anything just to protect Aaron from going to prison.
cyrilandshirley
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by Mr Men:
“Beating his lover which was deemed acceptable by many a fan. However when straight man Patrick Blake hits Maxine Minniver it is wrong.

He murdered and that to was ok because he was sexually abused and confused.

His one sided fued with Warren Fox despite that character being a big reason people started to take the show seriously, aka a fickle fanbase.
Silas Blissett has to be one of the shows best villains with Warren in it to at the same time. However low and behold he gets shoehorned into his plot and made out he was the better character.

His ending was pathetic as they couldn't be brave enough to kill him off.”

No, it wasn't. Not by anyone, ever. Watching people struggle with the dark side of life can be fascinating though.

Warren and Silas were also great though. It was never a competition.

But no point in talking about it! Got bored of the Brendan-bashing a long time ago. It's impossible to mention the guy's name and get a rational response. Shouldn't have bothered!

This thread is about Robert. Best get back to that.
cybersq
19-07-2015
Aaron has probably beaten up other parts of his body 😏
Mr Men
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by cyrilandshirley:
“No, it wasn't. Not by anyone, ever. Watching people struggle with the dark side of life can be fascinating though.

But no point in talking about it! Got bored of the Brendan-bashing a long time ago. It's impossible to mention the guy's name and get a rational response. Shouldn't have bothered.

This thread is about Robert. Best get back to that.”

Your response war not rational. You can't speak on behalf of EVERY fan. I remember friends and other forums excusing his beatingrg at the time.

I like BB but not in a cult following way.
Mr Men
19-07-2015
Originally Posted by cybersq:
“Aaron has probably beaten up other parts of his body 😏”

The dirt track pounding!

The fruit and 2 veg have been beaten to!
<<
<
1 of 2
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map