Originally Posted by Not the Hoople:
“I was waiting patiently for the new Hummy, but am not impressed by some of the news here, so await news on the Panny's - or I may just give up & get a BT Youview for £`150!”
The FVP-4000T is suffering from criticism of its epg compared with the Panasonic freeview play TVs. It is also suffering criticism in the UK because of the usability of the menus. Some critisism of new menus is understandable until we get use to the menus being different from what we are are used to, but in my view it is not just a question of getting use to the FVP-4000T menus. I am certain I would not be able to get use to the FVP-4000T,. For an example is what is splashed over so much of the picture when you pause or rewind or fast forward.
I own and use a number of PVRs with frequently a nominated primary one so that I force myself to get use to its features and menu design style.
I still find the Youview interface mildly irritating, but I'm sure it is better than what FVP-4000T is offering. I've decided not to buy and try out a FVP-4000T as I wouldn't know who to give it away to after I grow tired of it. I am confident that I would not want to keep it despite its features ticking so many boxes if the user interface is ignored.
The interface design of the FVP-4000T has been used before in some non-UK recorders. It is not good news that this Humax style of user interface is spreading. This reuse of the user interface is possibly a sign that Humax think that is not beneficial for their overall profits to invest in an improved user interface. I’m sort of hoping that the FVP-4000T’s interface is only a stop gap because ethey wanted to be the first to bring out a freeview play recorder and that Humax will bring out a replacement for the FVP-4000T with a much improved interface within a couple of years, but flying pigs also come to mind!
The usability of the user interface of the new Panasonic has yet to be discovered. Just because the Panasonic freeview play TV guide looks better then the Humax FVP-4000T is not a guarantee that the user interface of the Panasonic freeview play recorders will be any better than the FVP-4000T’s user interface.
Although the Youview interface is now only mildly irritating I would struggle if it was my only recorder. On the plus side It has catch-up, you can use its internet apps and it will still record from the schedule, the latter BT versions are quiet, fit in a small space behind my TV, have reasonable strength tuners but it is lacking in so much, when you press record on a live programme it records until the accurate recording end is triggered (unlike at least previous Humax freeview recorders), I also use a mini wireless keyboard to operate the Youview which is so much easier just hitting the keys rather than picking up and using a traditional remote control. The Youview lack of manual tuning for me means that Humax Youview recorders mistune and then miss recording because they gets confused between different transmitters (TalkTalk Youview don't suffer from this). Youview recorders have no manual timer function or auto-padding. Youview has no DLNA. In my opinion the Youview search function is poor. There is no archiving of recordings.
May be you don't need these but if you already have a PVR you may well find that a Youview box is lacking something that you have got used to and wouldn’t want to do without.
I am very wary of the flexibility of the Panasonic features. There have been reports of at least some of their previous Panasonic models being more restrictive than other brands with what you can do simultaneously. What I am thinking of here is if you are using one of the internet apps there have been reports of Panasonic recordings not taking place. With the new Panasonics I would also want to know if the archiving function enables standard definition and radio programmes to be pulled off so that they can be played on portable devices, though for some use of the TV anywhere app may be a better solution.
In my view £150 was a lot of money for the BT Youview recorder especial compared to a refurbished (i.e. latest software has been pre-installed) nippy freeview+ HD latest model of vestel recently available for a few months for under £40 (Bush B500DTRN and B320DTRN) even though BT Youview has more catch-up available.
I can see how tempting it is to just go out and buy the BT Youview and have done with the decision making. I suggest not giving up by buying a BT Youview for £150 quite yet unless you are prepared to risk that £150.
If you have a working PVR and are after catch-up an alternative temporary solution would be to buy one of the NowTV units. Their basic price is £15 but I haven't seen them recently without being bundled with some introductory package or sports passes which pushes the price up to £25. My understanding is that Sky now make you supply an email address to activate the box and there are the extra cables, but it would be a relatively cheap temporary solution until a clear individual winner was identified between one of the expected freeview play boxes and the BT Youview offerings.