Somehow it doesn't seem like The Spice Girls unless it's all five of them. When Geri left the group originally it wasn't the same anymore. They didn't last a lot longer either, without her, although I think their final album was atrocious anyway! Shame if Victoria won't be involved but she does have a successful career as a fashion designer now so I can understand her not wanting to get involved again. People always go on about her not being able to sing. I actually think she has the best tone of voice out of all the Spice Girls. She just doesn't have a very strong voice but she has a nice voice. Melanie C has the strongest voice but she can sound really nasally and strident at times. I've never rated Melanie B's voice that much but it's ok, I guess. Emma has a pleasant voice but, like Victoria's it's not a strong powerful voice. Geri was always the worst singer by far, in my opinion. I don't know if she's improved in recent years or not but I always thought she was pretty much tone deaf! The group were fun though and had some catchy songs like Stop, Spice Up Your Life, Say You'll Be Mine, Viva Forever and Too Much. Those are my favourite songs of theirs. I remember meeting them in the foyer of the Royal Albert Hall after the National Television Awards in 1996. It was just before Say You'll Be Mine was released and they all seemed so wide eyed and innocent back then. They were all so excited to be there and were so thrilled at having such a huge hit with Wannabe. They all posed for my camera, which was very cool and guess what - Victoria was SMILING in my photo, haha! A lovely big beaming smile!! She has a lovely smile, shame it's rarely seen in public these days. Dammit, was that really 19 years ago already?! Where has the time gone?!!!