Originally Posted by ftv:
“I watch it on my PVR early on Sundays so the scheduling doesn't really bother me.I seem to remember the BBC version was getting 800,000-900,000 even following MOTD.”
BBC One's ratings superiority over the commercial channels isn't news. And FLT isn't doing that badly compared to the BBC version, according to your own ballpark figure. As BBC One is roughly five times more popular than C5, you would expect FLT to have lost more than half its audience.
The fact it hasn't suggests the earlier timeslot has helped to an extent, but not enough for it to be a success. Move it post MOTD and the figure would fall to around 0.2m-0.25m no doubt which is something they might consider towards the end of the contract if things don't improve but surely not this early. Better to give it more time and work on improving the product in line with viewer feedback.
What has been most depressing about the failure of FLT thus far is the way this news has been gleefully received on here. If you're massively pro BBC you can't really spin it as testament to the power of being on that channel as the gap between the two programmes is smaller than it should be, so that doesn't work. As with all risks taken you win some and you lose some, but it's better than staying the same and not trying anything out of your comfort zone which is why TV in this country has become so stale. If it doesn't work, which looks very likely now, it'll soon end up back on everyone's beloved BBC, and people can get back to just leaving it on in the background after MOTD, only half watching and then moaning when the Beeb can't be bothered to do a show for Leagues One and Two only.